Article Text

PDF

The columnar lined oesophagus: a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma
  1. STUART JON SPECHLER
  1. Chief, Division of Gastroenterology, Dallas VA Medical Center, 4500 South Lancaster Road, Dallas, Texas 75216, USA

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    See article on page585

    Just a few years ago, the definition and pathogenesis of Barrett’s oesophagus seemed straightforward. Barrett’s oesophagus was the condition in which metaplastic columnar epithelium replaced oesophageal squamous mucosa that had been damaged by exposure to refluxed gastric juice. The condition was sought primarily in patients with gastro-oesophageal reflux disease (GORD), and was identified when endoscopic examination revealed long segments of columnar epithelium extending well up the oesophagus. Biopsy specimens taken from the oesophageal columnar lining usually showed a peculiar form of intestinal metaplasia called specialised columnar epithelium or specialised intestinal metaplasia. In patients who developed adenocarcinomas in Barrett’s oesophagus, the columnar epithelium surrounding the oesophageal tumour invariably contained specialised intestinal metaplasia that often exhibited dysplastic changes. Eventually, Barrett’s oesophagus with specialised intestinal metaplasia became recognised as the major risk factor for adenocarcinoma of the oesophagus and oesophagogastric junction.1

    Over the past two decades, the incidence of adenocarcinoma of the oesophagus and oesophagogastric junction has been rising dramatically in the United States and Western Europe.2 3 Patients who have oesophagectomy for adenocarcinoma at the oesophagogastric junction often do not have endoscopically apparent Barrett’s oesophagus, but rather have short, inconspicuous segments of specialised intestinal metaplasia found on histological examination of the resected specimens.4 In 1994, investigators who were aware of this phenomenon reported the results of a study designed to estimate the frequency of metaplastic changes in the distal oesophagus.5 In this study, consecutive patients scheduled for elective endoscopic examinations in a general endoscopy unit had biopsy specimens obtained at the squamocolumnar junction in the distal oesophagus (the Z-line) irrespective of its appearance and location. Among 142 patients who did not have endoscopically apparent Barrett’s oesophagus (that is, <3 cm of the distal oesophagus lined with columnar epithelium), the investigators were surprised to find that 26 (18%) had specialised intestinal metaplasia in biopsy specimens from the Z-line.

    Four similar studies, including one by Trudgill et al in this issue (see page 585), have been published since 1994 in peer-reviewed journals.6-8 The results of the five studies, all of which included consecutive, unselected patients seen in general endoscopy units, are summarised in table 1. The studies show clearly that short, inconspicuous segments of specialised intestinal metaplasia can be found frequently at the squamocolumnar junction in predominantly white patient populations. This may be the only clear point that emerges from these studies however. If specialised intestinal metaplasia indeed develops as a sequela of GORD, then one might expect an association with the symptoms and signs of reflux oesophagitis. However, only one study found a significant association with GORD symptoms whereas three did not, no study found any association with endoscopic oesophagitis, and only two of the four studies that sought an association with histological oesophagitis, found it. These observations challenge the traditional notion that oesophageal columnar metaplasia develops as a consequence of GORD, although further studies that include protracted oesophageal pH monitoring will be needed before this issue can be resolved. The potential contributions of Helicobacter pylori infection, inflammation in gastric cardiac epithelium, advancing age, race, and sex to the development of specialised intestinal metaplasia also are unclear. One study has suggested that the pathogenesis and epidemiology of specialised intestinal metaplasia at the squamocolumnar junction may vary substantially with the location of the Z-line.8 In this study, only white patients with GORD symptoms had specialised intestinal metaplasia found at the squamocolumnar junction when the Z-line was located within the distal oesophagus, whereas specialised intestinal metaplasia was found with similar frequency in both black and white patients irrespective of GORD symptoms when the Z-line was located precisely at the anatomical junction of oesophagus and stomach. For future studies, investigators will need to document meticulously the location of the Z-line with respect to the oesophagogastric junction. Finally, the cancer risk for patients with short segments of intestinal metaplasia in the distal oesophagus is not known. Considering the high prevalence of specialised intestinal metaplasia at the Z-line, and the infrequency of cancers at the oesophagogastric junction (despite the rising incidence rate), it would seem that the risk imposed by these short segments of specialised intestinal metaplasia is relatively small.

    Table 1

     Results of studies on the prevalence of specialised intestinal metaplasia (SIM) among unselected patients in general endoscopy units

    Today, the definition and pathogenesis of Barrett’s oesophagus no longer seem straightforward. Recent studies have raised far more questions than they have answered. If, as some have suggested, one defines Barrett’s oesophagus by the presence of any specialised intestinal metaplasia regardless of extent, then the aforementioned studies suggest that approximately one in every five patients seen in general endoscopy units has Barrett’s oesophagus. This definition does not seem appropriate. It seems preferable to call the condition “columnar lined oesophagus with specialised intestinal metaplasia”, rather than to use the artificial and emotionally charged term “Barrett’s oesophagus” that implies a strong association with GORD and cancer.9 Clearly, we have much to learn about the columnar lined oesophagus.

    See article on page585

    References

    View Abstract

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.