Article Text

Gastric bacterial overgrowth is a cause of false positive diagnosis of Helicobacter pylori infection using13C urea breath test
  1. L MICHAUD,
  2. F GOTTRAND,
  3. P S GANGA-ZANDZOU,
  4. N WIZLA-DERAMBURE,
  5. D TURCK
  1. Department of Paediatric Gastroenterology
  2. University Hospital of Lille, Lille, France
  3. Department of Bacteriology
  1. Dr Gottrand, Unité de Gastroentérologie, Hépatologie et Nutrition, Clinique de Pédiatrie, Hôpital Jeanne de Flandre, 59037 Lille, France.
  1. P VINCENT
  1. Department of Paediatric Gastroenterology
  2. University Hospital of Lille, Lille, France
  3. Department of Bacteriology
  1. Dr Gottrand, Unité de Gastroentérologie, Hépatologie et Nutrition, Clinique de Pédiatrie, Hôpital Jeanne de Flandre, 59037 Lille, France.

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Editor,—We read with interest the paper by Dominguez-Munos et al (Gut1997;40:459–62) describing an optimal test drink in the13C-urea breath test (13C UBT) for the diagnosis of Helicobacter pylori infection. In this study all H pylori negative subjects (adults with dyspeptic symptoms) had a negative result with the 13C UBT (specificity 100%) after different meals. In other studies, using13C UBT to document H pylori infection both in adults and children, the sensitivity of the test ranged from 92 to 100% whereas specificity was usually above 92%.1 2However, no explanation has been given for the occurrence of false positive tests. Methodological bias and problems in defining the cut off value are possible reasons. However, there are no explanations for some false positive tests.3 4 Here, we report two children with a positive 13C UBT resulting from the presence of urease positive bacteria other than H pyloriin the stomach.

A 14 month old girl operated on just after birth for a congenital diaphragmatic hernia and presenting with severe gastro-oesophageal reflux associated with oesophageal dilatation and swallowing dysfunction was referred because of gastro-oesophageal haemorrhage. Endoscopy revealed oesophageal dilatation, severe oesophagitis and gastric stasis. The gastric and duodenal mucosa appeared normal. She was treated for two months with H2 receptor antagonists. Antral and fundal biopsy samples (n=5) showed mild gastritis and wereH pylori negative on histology (Giemsa staining). Direct examination and culture of gastric biopsy specimens were both negative for H pylori. Serum specific antibodies against H pylori (ELISA) were also negative. 13C UBT was abnormal (5.63 δ%O; normal values <3 δ%O). Culture of gastric secretions revealed gastric bacterial overgrowth with colonic bacteria known to have urease activity (that is, Proteus mirabilis).

An 8 year old boy operated on just after birth for gastroschisis was referred because of a six month history of abdominal pain. Physical examination was normal. Endoscopy revealed moderate gastric stasis. Examination and culture of both antral and fundic biopsy specimens (n=5) were negative for H pylori as were serum specific antibodies against H pylori (ELISA).13C UBT was slightly abnormal (3.25 δ%O, normal values <3 δ%O). Culture of gastric secretions revealed gastric bacterial overgrowth with species, including micrococcus, with urease activity.

These two cases demonstrate that hydrolysis of urea as a result of bacterial metabolism can occur in the stomach of H pylorinegative subjects, and that 13C-urea can be hydrolysed in the presence of urease from bacterial species other than H pylori. Several bacteria—for example, P mirabilis,Escherichia coli, Yersinia enterocolita, Klebsiella pneumoniae, Staphylococcus aureus, have urease activity, but they do not usually colonise the stomach. Gastric bacterial overgrowth was probably favoured by prolonged antisecretory treatment in the first case and by gastric emptying abnormalities in the second (intestinal malrotation associated with gastroschisis). Urease activity associated with H pylori infection usually causes greater excretion of13C than that observed in our two patients (5.6 and 3.25 δ%O respectively). As the cut off value of 3.00 δ%O has been validated in both adults and children2 3 and no technical bias occurred, false positive resuts can be ruled out in our patients.

In summary, the 13C UBT is a sensitive and specific method for the non-invasive detection of H pylori infection, but gastric bacterial overgrowth may lead to a false positive diagnosis. These patients may be wrongly considered to be H pylori positive if a single, non-invasive test is used. In some circumstances (long term use of antisecretory drugs or abnormalities of gastric motility) a low positive 13C UBT without other evidence of H pylori infection (serology, bacteriology, histology) may be suggestive of gastric bacterial overgrowth.Letters, Book reviews, Notes

References

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.