Article Text


Variable phenotype of familial adenomatous polyposis in pedigrees with 3′ mutation in the APC gene


Background—Germline mutation in the adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) gene on chromosome 5 causes familial adenomatous polyposis. “Attenuated” phenotype has been reported with mutation in the 5′ end of the gene (5′ to codon 158), but genotype-phenotype relations at the 3′ end (3′ to codon 1596) have not been described fully.

Aims—To describe and compare colorectal and extracolonic phenotypes in a case series of families with mutation in the 3′ end of the APC gene.

Methods—Thirty one at risk or affected members from four families with a mutation in the APC gene located at codon 1979 or 2644 were evaluated.

Results—Variable intrapedigree colorectal phenotype was observed: some members at older age had oligopolyposis (fewer than one hundred colorectal adenomas) whereas other members had classic polyposis at young age. Colorectal cancer was diagnosed at older mean age (50 (7) years) in the four families than in classic FAP pedigrees (39 (14) years). Extracolonic lesions characteristic of FAP occurred with 3′ APC mutations, but variability in intrapedigree and interpedigree extracolonic phenotype and dissociation of severity of extracolonic manifestations from number of colorectal polyps was noted.

Conclusions—Families with 3′ mutations of the APC gene exhibit variable intrapedigree phenotype similar to the heterogeneity noted in families with proximal 5′ mutations. Genotyping of FAP and oligopolyposis pedigrees can guide appropriate surveillance of the upper and lower gastrointestinal tract in affected members.

  • familial adenomatous polyposis
  • attenuated adenomatous polyposis coli
  • adenomatous polyposis coli gene mutation
  • extracolonic lesions

Statistics from

Familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP) is an autosomal dominant disease classically characterised by the development of hundreds of adenomatous colorectal polyps, usually in the teenage years.1 Most affected individuals who are not treated with colectomy develop colorectal cancer by the sixth decade of life.2 Germline mutations in the adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) gene, located on the long arm of chromosome 5 in band q21, cause FAP.3-6 The APC gene has 15 exons and encodes a predicted gene product of 2843 amino acids with a molecular weight of about 312 000 daltons. Both frameshift and point mutations of the APC gene occur in FAP and are generally distributed in the 5′ half of the coding region.

Genotype-phenotype correlation studies have reported that mutations in the extreme 5′ end of the APC gene are associated with a less severe phenotype of FAP,7-15 termed attenuated adenomatous polyposis coli (AAPC) by Spirio et al in 1992.11 The clinical characteristics of the attenuated variant include fewer than 100 colorectal adenomas (oligopolyposis) at presentation but notable phenotypic variation within pedigrees, and a delayed onset of colorectal cancer which occurs on average 12 years later than in classic FAP.10 12 15 Further evaluation revealed that APC mutations 5′ to codon 158 (proximal 5′ mutations) predict the attenuated phenotype, while mutations 3′ to codon 167 are associated with classic FAP.10

Recently, several pedigrees with mutations in the distal 3′ portion of the APC gene have also been reported to have an attenuated phenotype.16-25 These pedigrees have mutations of the APC gene 3′ to codon 1596, while mutations of codons 1444 to 1578 have been associated with classic polyposis and multiple extracolonic manifestations.26 27 We performed a detailed evaluation of the phenotype of four families with mutations that occurred in codon 1979 or 2644 and compared them to other reports of families with distal 3′ mutations. The implications for clinical management of patients in these pedigrees are addressed.


At the time of this study, The Johns Hopkins Polyposis Registry contained 340 pedigrees with FAP. After informed consent was obtained, at least one member with FAP from 112 available pedigrees was evaluated for mutation of the APC gene. The APC gene was analysed using DNA and/or RNA from peripheral blood leucocytes by in vitro synthesised protein (IVSP) assay and/or cloning and sequencing the entire coding region of the gene, as described previously.27-29 Only two of the registry families were found to carry a mutation 3′ to codon 1596 (families 1 and 4). Two additional families with mutation in this region (families 2 and 3) are included. Family 2 is reported in collaboration with Indiana University Medical Center, Indianapolis, Indiana, and family 3 with the University of Colorado Cancer Center, Denver, Colorado.

The records of the members from these four families with mutation in the 3′ region of the APC gene were reviewed in detail. The age at diagnosis of FAP, number of polyps at first examination of the colon, age at diagnosis of colorectal cancer, and extracolonic manifestations were evaluated in the members of each pedigree. The diagnosis of FAP in family members was verified by clinical and pathological criteria. The age of colorectal cancer diagnosis in these 3′ pedigrees was compared with that of FAP families from the Johns Hopkins Polyposis Registry with mutations 5′ to codon 1596.15


Families 1–3 had a four base pair deletion (ACAA) at codon 1979, which resulted in a detectable truncated protein by IVSP assay. There was no evidence of a founder effect for these three families. Family 4 had a four base pair deletion (TTAT) at codon 2644 which did not produce a truncated protein by IVSP assay.

The pedigrees are shown in fig 1 and summarised in tables 1 and 2. In the three families which had multiple affected members (families 1, 2, and 4), heterogeneity in the colorectal phenotype within each family was noted (table 1). Gene test results were available for multiple members in families 1 and 2. There were seven gene positive people ranging in age from 22 to 46, each with fewer than seven adenomas on colonic examination, representing oligopolyposis. By contrast, there were five people with polyposis (greater than 100 polyps) diagnosed between 25 and 74 years of age in these same pedigrees. For example, in family 2, subjects III:2 and III:3 (fig 1) had profuse polyposis necessitating colectomy at ages 25 and 28.

Figure 1

Pedigrees of families 1–4 with 3′ mutation of the APC gene.

Table 1

Clinical characteristics of individual family members

Table 2

Molecular genetic test results and phenotype of families reported in literature

Extracolonic manifestations characteristic of FAP (table 1) also showed intrafamilial variation and did not correlate with phenotypic expression of colorectal polyposis. Individual II-6 in family 1 had only four colorectal adenomas at age 44, but she had multiple fundic gland retention polyps of the stomach. Similarly, subjects II:5, III:3, and III:4 were all affected with skin lesions, despite the presence of very few if any colorectal polyps. In family 2, individual III:1 had sebaceous cysts but only three colorectal adenomas at age 33. The great variety of extracolonic manifestations contrasted with the lack of typical colonic polyposis. Also, despite identical mutations of codon 1979 in families 1–3, interfamilial variability in the severity of extracolonic manifestations was evident (tables 1 and 2).

Four cases of colorectal cancer with known age of cancer diagnosis were noted at 46, 46, 48, and 60 years of age in families 1, 2, and 4. The average age at diagnosis of colorectal cancer (50 (SD 7) years) contrasted with the younger age of colorectal cancer diagnosis (39 (14) years) in classic FAP families in the Johns Hopkins Polyposis Registry.15 29 Two patients in whom colorectal polyp number was known had polyposis (more than 100 adenomas) at the time of cancer diagnosis (polyp number in patient I:2 in family 2 and patient III:1 in family 4 could not be quantitated). None of the patients with fewer than 100 adenomas developed colorectal cancer.


We found that mutation in the 3′ end of the APC gene was associated with intrapedigree variability of both colonic and extracolonic phenotype, as evidenced by families 1, 2, and 4 which had multiple affected members available for study. Intrapedigree variability of colorectal phenotype has been noted by other investigators in subjects presumed to be genotypically affected, as reviewed in table 1. Similar variability is also seen in the colorectal phenotype of all pedigrees described to date with mutations 5′ to codon 158.15 Analogous to the boundary for phenotypic manifestations of mutations at the 5′ end of the APC gene, a boundary at the 3′ end of the gene at codon 1596 separates families with variable intrapedigree phenotype from classic FAP phenotype.

The evolution of colorectal cancer seemed to parallel expression of colorectal polyposis in our study. The two individuals with colorectal cancer and information about the number of polyps both had classic polyposis. An older mean age at diagnosis of colorectal cancer (50 (7) years) was noted in these four patients in families 1, 2, and 4 compared with classic FAP pedigrees.29 This is consistent with the delayed development of colorectal cancer observed in AAPC families with proximal 5′ mutations.15 Nevertheless, the cumulative risk of colorectal cancer seems to reach 100% in attenuated adenomatous polyposis caused by 5′ mutation of the APC gene,15 and 3′ families may follow a similar course.19

Extracolonic manifestations characteristic of FAP also showed intrafamilial variation and did not correlate with phenotypic expression of colorectal polyposis. The great variety of extracolonic manifestations in family members contrasted with the frequent occurrence of oligopolyposis. This phenomenon has also been described by others.20 21 Specifically, Eccles et al 20 reported a family (with a 2 bp insertion at codon 1924 of the APC gene) with hereditary desmoid disease and the presence of other extracolonic manifestations including osteomas, fibromas, and epidermoid cysts, but only one member with colorectal polyps.

Although the four families included in our series were the only ones known to us with mutations 3′ to codon 1596, each pedigree included at least one member with classic polyposis (more than 100 polyps) who led to APC gene testing of the family. Our study results are, therefore, biased by selection on the basis of classic disease phenotype. Individuals with oligopolyposis in the absence of a family history of classic disease could also have mutation in the 3′ or 5′ region of the APC gene but would not have been tested.

Recognition that an attenuated colorectal phenotype can occur in some patients with germline mutations of the APC gene makes routine genotyping of families with multiple adenomas important for clinical management. Colonoscopic rather than sigmoidoscopic screening of at risk members to evaluate the entire colon is appropriate when mutations involve the proximal or distal end of the APC gene because of the occurrence of oligopolyposis.30 Also, gene positive members of families with variable intrapedigree phenotype should consider surveillance with oesophogastroduodenoscopy even before the development of colorectal polyposis, as several study subjects had upper gastrointestinal polyposis rather than colorectal polyposis. Finally, because of the possibility of a 3′ or 5′ APC mutation, this study argues that APC gene testing should be considered for patients with small numbers of adenomas (10 or more) if they present at young age (less than 40 years), with extracolonic lesions characteristic of FAP, or with a family history of adenomas and/or cancer.


We are indebted to Drs Kenneth W Kinzler and Bert Vogelstein for their contributions to analysis of the APC gene mutations. We thank Dr Paul J Raiman for assistance in data collection, Ms Lisa Mullineaux for genetic counselling support, and Ms Linda Welch for technical support. Supported in part by The Clayton Fund, The University of Colorado Cancer Center, and NIH grants CA 62924, CA 53801, CA 95–21, CA 63721, and CA 46934.


View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Linked Articles