Long term outcome of patients with gastric marginal zone B cell lymphoma of mucosa associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) following exclusive Helicobacter pylori eradication therapy: experience from a large prospective series
- 1Department of Internal Medicine, Klinikum Aschaffenburg, Aschaffenburg, Germany
- 2Medizinische Poliklinik, University of Würzburg, Würzburg, Germany
- 3Gesundheitszentrum Süd, Vienna, Austria
- 4Institute of Pathology, Klinikum Bayreuth, Bayreuth, Germany
- 5Institute of Pathology, University of Würzburg, Würzburg, Germany
- Correspondence to:
Professor W Fischbach
Medizinische Klinik II, Klinikum Aschaffenburg, Am Hasenkopf, D-63739 Aschaffenburg, Germany;
- Accepted 5 August 2003
Background:Helicobacter pylori plays a decisive role in the pathogenesis of gastric marginal zone B cell lymphoma of mucosa associated lymphoid tissue (MALT), and eradication therapy has become a widely accepted initial treatment of stage I disease.
Objective: To determine the long term outcome of patients undergoing exclusive H pylori eradication therapy.
Design: A prospective series of patients with newly diagnosed marginal zone B cell lymphoma of MALT.
Setting: Multicentre study in Germany and Austria.
Patients: Ninety five patients; 90 of these (five lost to follow up) with a mean age of 54.3 (27–85) years were followed up for at least 12 months.
Intervention: Complete staging work up revealing stage I disease and H pylori infection. Patients received triple therapy (OMC: omeprazole 20 mg twice daily, metronidazole 400 mg twice daily, and clarithromycin 250 mg twice daily; or OAC: omeprazole 20 mg twice daily, amoxycillin 1000 mg twice daily, and clarithromycin 500 twice daily) for one week.
Results: Median follow up was 44.6 (12–89) months. H pylori was successfully eradicated in 88 patients (98%); in two patients eradication therapy failed. Long term outcome was characterised by complete regression of lymphoma in 56 patients (62%), minimal residual disease in 17 patients (18%), partial remission in 11 patients (12%), no change in four patients (4%), and progressive disease in two patients (2%). Four patients with complete remission relapsed after 6, 8, 8, and 15 months, one revealing reinfection by H pylori. Regression rate was higher in stage I1 disease compared with stage I2, as diagnosed by endoscopic ultrasound.
Conclusion: The majority of patients with low grade gastric MALT lymphoma treated by exclusive H pylori eradication have a favourable long term outcome, offering a real chance of cure.
- MALT, mucosa associated lymphoid tissue
- OMC, omeprazole, metronidazole, and clarithromycin
- OAC, omeprazole, amoxycillin, and clarithromycin
- EUS, endoscopic ultrasound
There is strong evidence from epidemiological, histomorphological, and experimental data that infection of the gastric mucosa by Helicobacter pylori plays a decisive role in the development and progression of marginal zone B cell lymphoma of the mucosa associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) type.1–10 This convincing evidence of a pathogenetic link led to a new approach towards treatment. Nowadays, eradication of H pylori is considered the well accepted initial therapy in cases of localised (stage I) low grade gastric MALT lymphoma.11 However, data on the long term outcome of patients undergoing exclusive eradication therapy are rare, and the curative potential of this strategy is still under debate. We report a large prospective series of 90 patients with a follow up of at least 12 months.
From March 1993 onwards, 95 patients were diagnosed as having gastric marginal zone B cell lymphoma of the MALT type by centralised histological review. The diagnosis was based on morphological and immunophenotypic analysis of paraffin embedded sections and, when available, fresh frozen material. Histological work up followed the criteria described by Isaacson and Norton12 and the REAL/WHO classification.13,14 The endoscopic biopsy protocol comprised 8–12 samples of visible lesions and two separate biopsies from macroscopically normal mucosa of the antrum and corpus.
Complete staging work up, including abdominal and cervical ultrasound, computed tomography scan of the chest and abdomen, bone marrow puncture, small bowel radiography, ileocolonoscopy, and endoscopic ultrasound (EUS) revealed stage I according to the Ann Arbor staging system with its modifications by Musshoff15 and Radaszkiewicz and colleagues.16 Due to lack of availability, EUS could not be performed in 10 cases.
H pylori infection was diagnosed if the urease rapid test, histology, or the 13C urea breath test were positive. Triple therapy using omeprazole (2×20 mg/day), clarithromycin (2×250 mg/day and 2×500 mg/day, respectively), and metronidazole (2×400 mg/day) (OMC) or amoxycillin (2×1000 mg/day) (OAC) was given for seven days. Follow up examinations including endoscopy and ultrasound were carried out at three monthly intervals during the first two years, and every six months thereafter.
Ninety of the patients (33 female, 57 male; mean age 54.3 years (range 27–85)) were evaluated for their state of remission at 12 months after eradication therapy; five patients were lost to follow up. Complete remission was defined as total disappearance of lymphoma and absence of histopathological evidence of lymphoma on endoscopic biopsy. Partial remission was assumed in cases of tumour reduction of at least 50%. Patients revealing normalisation of macroscopic findings but with persistent residual lymphoma infiltrates on histological examination were classified as minimal residual disease.
In cases of non-response to H pylori eradication, defined as clinically or histologically progressive disease at any control, partial remission, or no change 12 months after successful eradication of H pylori, patients were referred for surgery or radiotherapy. In those with minimal residual disease, any oncological treatment was postponed on condition of very thorough endoscopic-bioptic controls.
To estimate the effect of H pylori eradication therapy on lymphoma status, intention to treat analysis was applied.
The study was approved by the ethics committees of the Universities of Würzburg and Vienna. All patients gave written informed consent.
Median follow up was 44.6 months (range 12–89). H pylori eradication was successful in 88 patients (98%); in two patients eradication therapy failed. Long term outcome was characterised by complete regression of lymphoma in 56 patients (62%), minimal residual disease in 17 patients (18%), partial remission in 11 patients (12%), no change in four patients (4%), and progressive disease in two patients (2%). Figure 1 summarises the long term outcome of all 90 patients.
Four patients relapsed, three with a low grade lymphoma after 8, 8, and 15 months, respectively, and one with a high grade lymphoma after six months. At the time of relapse, only one patient presented with reinfection by H pylori. Additional antibiotic treatment was successful with respect to both bacterial eradication and regression of lymphoma in this patient. He remains free of relapse to date. Two further patients with no change in lymphoma infiltration after eradication therapy were diagnosed as having high grade lymphoma components by endoscopic-bioptic restaging. Two patients died, one from postoperative sepsis after non-response to H pylori eradication therapy and one from causes unrelated to lymphoma or its treatment. Patients with minimal residual disease one year after eradication therapy did not reveal any signs of lymphoma progression, spread of disease, or high grade transformation. In two, late complete remission became evident 15 and 19 months after eradication of H pylori.
Complete regression of the lymphoma was observed in 50 of 80 patients (62.5%) who were classified as stage I disease by EUS (table 1). In 23 of 50 cases, the endoscopist was unable to differentiate stages I1 and I2 by describing the exact depth of tumour infiltration. The rate of complete regression increased from stage I2 (4/9; 44%) to stage I1 (23/42; 55%).
In the late 1980s, acquisition of intramucosal lymph follicles and accumulation of immunoglobulin A producing plasma cells were found to result from H pylori infection of the gastric mucosa.1,2,17 This acquired lymphatic tissue showed morphological characteristics of MALT and regressed after successful eradication of the bacterium.18 In 1991, Wotherspoon and colleagues3 for the first time demonstrated that patients with primary gastric MALT lymphoma are regularly infected by H pylori. Since then, this finding has been confirmed by other investigators.4,18,19 In addition to histomorphological studies, recent epidemiological,5,6 molecular biological,8–10 and experimental7 data clearly indicate that H pylori plays a decisive role in the development and progression of gastric MALT lymphoma. This convincing evidence inevitably involved a therapeutic effort. In 1993, Wotherspoon and colleagues20 reported complete regression of low grade lymphoma following successful H pylori eradication in five of six cases. Prospective trials have confirmed this observation21–26 and reported rates of complete regression of lymphoma varying between 56% and 100%.
Undoubtedly, eradication of H pylori represents a fascinating therapeutic option because of both its simplicity and efficacy. However, data on long term outcome are currently rare. To our knowledge, our series is one of the largest prospective studies on H pylori eradication therapy in gastric MALT lymphoma, and with a median follow up of more than four years comprises one of the longest observation periods. In 1999, Isaacson described a six year follow up of the first six patients who were successfully treated by H pylori eradication.27 Although transient histological or molecular relapse has been observed in some patients, prolonged disease free remission was documented in all patients with or without molecular evidence of a monoclonal B cell population. The overall complete lymphoma regression rate in our study of 62.5% does not differ considerably from studies with a shorter follow up.21–26
Assessment of the depth of lymphoma infiltration by endoscopy and EUS has thus far been shown to have predictive value.23,26,28–30 However, the findings reported in these studies vary widely. While Ruskoné-Fourmestraux et al describe complete remission rates as high as 79% in lymphomas infiltrating the mucosa only,28 Steinbach et al achieved complete remission in stage 1 patients of no more than 56%.26 What are the possible explanations for these discrepancies? It has to be kept in mind that the diagnostic accuracy of EUS in the local staging of gastric lymphoma is limited. We found that EUS correctly identified only 53% of patients compared with the gold standard of pathohistological stage of the resected specimen.31 This was a multicentre study, thus probably reflecting the situation in a more realistic way than results from highly specialised gastroenterology units.28,30 Finally, experience with EUS was limited at the time this study started. We strongly believe that with increasing experience of endoscopists and technical improvements such as the use of small ultrasound probes (mini-echoendoscopes) and ultrasound guided biopsy facilities, EUS as a predictive factor of lymphoma remission will become substantially more accurate. Considering the diagnostic uncertainty on the one hand and possible regression of lymphoma even in locally more advanced stages, we would not at present exclude patients with infiltration of the submucosa or muscularis propria from eradication therapy. However, they may need a more intensive follow up.
Relapse was found in four patients, one of whom had a high grade lymphoma. In view of the comparatively short time period (six months) until relapse recurred in the latter patient, it remains a matter of speculation whether this was in fact recurrence or previously undiagnosed high malignant foci of the initial lymphoma. According to our experience in 266 patients with primary gastric B cell lymphoma, approximately 18% reveal synchronous low grade and high grade components.24 The fact that high grade lymphoma was found in only three patients (fig 1) allows two conclusions to be drawn. Firstly, the risk of high malignant transformation in patients treated by exclusive H pylori eradication appears to be low. Secondly, a subtle endoscopic-bioptic technique (gastric mapping), as performed here, minimises sampling errors.
With respect to both the rate of relapse and H pylori reinfection, our data are very similar to those reported by Neubauer and colleagues.25 In their prospective series of 50 patients, they observed four cases of local recurrence, only one being accompanied by H pylori reinfection. Another patient developed a high grade nasal lymphoma. This study offers another highly interesting aspect. In 22 of 31 patients (71%) with continuous complete remission, monoclonal B cells persisted. The biological significance of these cells is not clear at present.
Eighteen per cent of patients studied were characterised by normalised endoscopic and endosonographic findings but persistent lymphoma infiltrates (minimal residual disease). Despite well established criteria to refer such patients to surgery or radiotherapy, we decided on a watch and wait strategy after extensive and repeated information from the patients. Our findings that they did well during further follow up, focus on a possibly favourable natural course of minimal residuals of low grade gastric MALT type lymphoma after successful eradication of H pylori. Molecular analyses were beyond the scope of this multicentre study. With respect to translocation t(11;18), discordant results have been published recently.32–35 There is some evidence that t(11;18) positive lymphoma are characterised by a more advanced tumour stage and failure to respond to H pylori eradication therapy.32,33 On the other hand, t(11;18) negative lymphoma reveal more clonal aberrations and are prone to progress more frequently to high grade lymphoma.34 In a small series, we have shown that minimal residuals of low grade gastric MALT type lymphoma patients being t(11;18) positive may have a favourable course of disease.35 Hence a watch and wait strategy may become an option in such a situation.
In summary, H pylori eradication is an effective treatment modality in gastric marginal zone B cell lymphoma of MALT. The majority of patients treated exclusively in this way have a favourable long term outcome, offering a real chance of cure.
Supported by a grant from the Deutsche Krebshilfe (German Cancer Research Foundation).
Presented and published as an abstract at the Digestive Disease Week, Atlanta, May 2001.