Statistics from Altmetric.com
In primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC), annular fibrosis around intrahepatic and extrahepatic bile ducts leads to progressive liver disease for which there is no effective therapy except liver transplantation.1 The concentric accumulation of connective tissue around bile ducts suggests that the cholangiocyte plays an integral role in PSC pathogenesis. However, what initiates changes in cholangiocyte phenotype and how cholangiocytes interact with cells in the peribiliary extracellular matrix like immune cells and stromal components is largely unknown. Over the last 10 years, genome-wide association studies in PSC have revealed >20 risk genes.2–5 A significant observation that can be derived from these data, which also applies to other non-Mendelian phenotypes, is that the predominant risk contribution is likely to come from one or more environmental sources, rather than the genetic aberrations. Indeed, in PSC, we estimate that <10% of the overall liability is accounted for by the genetic findings; with extrapolations into hypothetical, larger study populations, it is unlikely to exceed 30%–40%.6 7 Research dissecting the remaining environmental contribution to PSC and other complex diseases is methodologically challenging. The exposures of an organism throughout life as a whole have recently been referred to as the exposome8 and include a myriad of components of both the external (eg, xenobiotics) and internal (eg, gut microbes) milieu.
There is a long tradition and effective means for detecting infectious exposures in medicine. Robert Koch in the late 19th century proposed criteria to identify a disease as infectious.9 These included (i) the organism is regularly associated with the disease, (ii) the organism can be isolated from the diseased host and grown in culture and (iii) the disease can be reproduced when the organism is introduced into a healthy susceptible host. With the development of nucleic acid sequence-based identification of microbes, as well as the recognition that the behaviour of a particular microbe can be influenced by the community in which it resides, Koch’s original postulates have evolved.10 11 More specifically, the concept has developed to incorporate culture-independent techniques that can identify putative pathogen nucleic acid sequences or even microbe-derived products (eg, short-chain fatty acids) in association with a diseased tissue that decrease with resolution of disease and increase with clinical relapse.11 These ideas suggest that ‘the scientific community should consider infectious disease causation in a broader systems biology context …’ and ‘… as technology advances and new scientific discoveries are made, there must be dynamic adaptation of Koch’s postulates …’.10 Recent examples of an expanded paradigm thus incorporate the transfer of body weight-associated, IgA-associated or liver injury-associated gut microbiota in causation of obesity, IBD or alcoholic hepatitis, respectively.12–14
There is less of a tradition and only preliminary tools to detect non-infectious environmental exposures in medicine. In light of the strong environmental component in PSC liability determined by the genetic studies, a reconsideration as to how PSC may fulfil the revised Koch’s criteria is however timely. A rationale for this proposition can be made on several sets of considerations, each of which will be addressed in this commentary. These include (i) the evolution of Koch’s postulates to account for complex exposure-driven disease,10 11for example, obesity and IBD12 15; (ii) similarities in cholangiocyte phenotype and downstream signalling pathways between secondary sclerosing cholangitis (SSC) due to a direct microbial infection (eg, Cryptosporidium parvum)16 and PSC; (iii) accumulating evidence supporting a critical role for the intestinal microbiome in the pathogenesis of PSC17; (iv) a similar genetic architecture in PSC as in a prototypical exposure-driven autoimmune disease, coeliac disease18; and (v) a similar genetic architecture in PSC as in cholestatic drug-induced injury.19 20
We began studying the cholangiopathy in HIV-infected patients (a form of SSC due to biliary tract infection by opportunistic pathogens, including C parvum)21 both because it was a significant clinical problem and as a result of our own clinical experience with C parvum-induced SSC.22 To summarise key points from multiple in vitro and in vivo studies,16 23 we found that C parvum, presumably via retrograde invasion of the biliary tree from the small intestine, resulted in a pro-inflammatory, activated cholangiocyte phenotype and that the process involved a number of key molecules (eg, toll-like receptors, nuclear factor KB, C/EBP Beta and NRAS).24 25 Moreover, the infection was associated with altered cholangiocyte cytokine and miRNA expression26 27 as well as inflammation and fibrosis.16 More recently, and relevant to this commentary, we noted that virtually all of the changes described as a result of cholangiocyte invasion by C parvum also occurred when microbial-derived products (eg, lipopolysaccharide, flagellin) were used as an alternative to the microbe itself.25 28 Additionally, cholangiocytes in vitro develop a senescent phenotype (ie, proliferative arrest), likely involving these same pathways and processes, when chronically exposed to microbial-derived- products29 (figure 1). Importantly, we discovered that these pathways and processes are likely operative in human PSC.
A series of divergent published and unpublished data are evolving that independently suggest, from a different perspective, microbial contributions to PSC. These data in patients with PSC include (i) expression of microbial receptors on cholangiocytes,30 and the occurrence of bacterobilia,31 32 (iii) bacteraemia of the portal venous system,33 (iv) promising results of antibiotics in uncontrolled studies34–37 and (v) genomic associations with loci implicated in host/microbiome interactions.38 The clinical relationship between the gut (including potentially those microbes that reside therein) and the liver in PSC was established 50 years ago with the observation that PSC frequently occurred in the setting of IBD.39 40 A series of studies recently published in Gut have demonstrated that the gut microbiome in PSC is distinct from those microbial communities observed in IBD patients without PSC and healthy controls.41–44 The relationship between the gut microbial communities and the liver is bidirectional, meaning that there is an impact from host factors onto the gut microbiota by bile and intestinal secretions and the immune system, as much as from microbial metabolites and constituents provided via the gut mucosa and the portal circulation (figure 2).17 Support for a role of intestinal microbiota in PSC also comes from studies performed in germ-free mice. In the biliary bile acid toxicity model (Abcb4-/-), an aggravation of bile duct disease was observed in the germ-free animals compared with conventionally raised mice.45 In contrast, in the immune-driven NOD.c3c4 model, an amelioration of bile duct disease was observed in the germ-free animals.46 These differences highlight the complexity of the relationship between gut-derived exposures and the liver and the bile ducts, and suggest that various components of PSC pathogenesis may be affected differently. Further studies are now urgently needed to link the microbial community alterations of PSC and their metabolic and immunological consequences for hepatobiliary physiology and disease.
Given the above considerations supporting the importance of the environment in the pathogenesis of PSC, many key questions remain largely unanswered. For example, what is the nature of a potential environmental exposure in PSC? Is it a small molecule or a peptide-derived substance? Is it dietary or microbial in origin (or both, meaning xenobiotic transformed by microbial metabolism)? Is it singular and specific in nature (like gluten in coeliac disease) or is it a compound microbial impact (like most likely the case in Crohn’s disease)? Are there different factors responsible for triggering and driving disease, respectively? At this time, answers to these questions can only be provided based on circumstantial evidence. From the genetic perspective, the strong human leucocyte antigen (HLA) class II associations (DRB1) are suggestive of at least one singular causative compound of key importance, similar to the situation in coeliac disease or drug-induced injury (figure 3).47 In comparison, the genetic architecture of non-autoimmune, inflammatory diseases like Crohn’s disease is largely different (figure 3), possibly due to a broader spectrum of environmental factors being involved. Further to this thinking, in coeliac disease and drug-induced liver injury, the site of metabolism is crucial for disease localisation (in coeliac disease by transglutaminase 2 in the proximal intestine, in drug-induced liver injury in the liver). In PSC, disease distribution stretches across the distal ileum throughout most of the colon (with a right-sided predominance) into the entire surface of the intrahepatic and extrahepatic bile ducts. Our knowledge of the metabolic machinery of the epithelium in the biliary fraction of this surface (cholangiocytes) is still relatively rudimentary compared with hepatocytes and enterocytes. This also makes assessments as to what could be the components involved with causative factors very difficult. Possibly, as shown in figure 4, working from the currently known genetic co-variables of PSC development, HLA class II in particular, is a more direct way of determining the identity of causative factors than unbiased –omics technologies providing broad, correlative data.
In summary, the evolution of Koch’s postulates based on the availability of new technologies, the similarities in the intracellular signalling pathways, processes and pathophysiological outcomes of SSC versus PSC, as well as recent data strongly implicating an important role for the intestinal microbiome in PSC, all justify serious consideration and further experiments to test the possibility that PSC is caused by an environmental exposure. Genetic and environmental factors are inseparable and co-dependent in the causation of PSC as in any disease, and specific genetic findings made over the last decade, HLA related in particular, may for this reason guide the way forward in a methodologically challenging research space. The molecular machinery of the cholangiocyte is likely to play a key role at this gene–environment intersection, and basic research to enhance our understanding of normal and activated cholangiocyte function is urgently needed to test for their involvement with putative pathogenic factors.
Contributors All authors have contributed equally to the article.
Competing interests None declared.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.