BACKGROUND It has been suggested that slow transit constipation (STC) may be part of a panenteric motor disorder.
AIM To evaluate motility of an upper gastrointestinal organ, the gall bladder, in 16 patients with STC and 20 healthy controls.
METHODS Gall bladder emptying (ultrasonography) was studied in response to neural, cephalic-vagal stimulation with modified sham feeding (MSF) for 90 minutes and in response to hormonal stimulation with cholecystokinin (CCK, 0.5 IDU/kg/h) for 60 minutes.
RESULTS Fasting gall bladder volume in patients with STC (17 (2) cm3) was significantly (p<0.01) reduced compared with that in controls (24 (2) cm3). Gall bladder emptying in response to MSF was significantly reduced in patients with STC expressed both as percentage emptying (11 (5)% versus 22 (3)%; p<0.05) and as absolute emptying (2.1 (0.7) cm3 versus 4.9 (0.7) cm3; p<0.02). However, percentage gall bladder emptying in response to CCK was not different between patients and controls (73 (4)% versus 67 (4)%) although the absolute reduction in gall bladder volume was significantly (p<0.05) smaller in patients (10.7 (1.1) cm3versus 15.3 (1.4) cm3).
CONCLUSIONS Patients with slow transit constipation have smaller fasting gall bladder volumes, impaired gall bladder responses to vagal cholinergic stimulation, but normal gall bladder responses to hormonal stimulation with CCK. These results point to abnormalities in gastrointestinal motility proximal from the colon in slow transit constipation and more specifically, impaired neural responsiveness.
- slow transit constipation
- gall bladder emptying
- sham feeding
Abbreviations used in this paper
- body mass index
- deoxycholic acid
- modified sham feeding
- peptide YY
- slow transit constipation
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Patients with severe chronic constipation can be subdivided into those with outlet obstruction, those with slow transit constipation (STC), and those with normal transit constipation.1 In case of long term persistence of STC and failure of conventional drug treatment, (sub)total colectomy is considered. However, the value of surgery in these patients has been questioned as symptoms of delayed transit persist in a considerable number of patients after (sub)total colectomy.2-8Therefore it has been suggested that, apart from alterations in colonic function, proximal gastrointestinal function might be abnormal as well. Recently it has been hypothesised that chronic constipation is part of a more generalised gastrointestinal motility disorder.8Alterations in small bowel motility,9-11 gastric emptying,9 ,11 and gastrointestinal hormone release12 have been described and support the concept that severe idiopathic constipation may be part of a panenteric disorder.
To investigate this hypothesis further, we have studied whether gall bladder emptying is abnormal in severely constipated patients with slow colonic transit when compared with healthy controls. Gall bladder motor function can be assessed non-invasively by ultrasonography. As constipation has been associated with autonomic neuropathy,10 ,13 ,14 gall bladder emptying was studied in response to vagal cholinergic stimulation with modified sham feeding. In addition, the gall bladder response to cholecystokinin, an important hormonal mediator of gall bladder contraction,15 was evaluated.
Patients and methods
Severe chronic idiopathic constipation was defined by a stool frequency of two times per week or less, persistent for at least 12 months. Patients with outlet obstruction or organic pathology were excluded, as well as patients who had previously undergone abdominal surgery. According to these criteria, a total number of 16 patients with constipation were included. The patient group consisted of 15 women and one man with a mean age of 39 (SEM 3) years and a mean body mass index (BMI) of 22 (0.6) kg/m2. All patients had a long standing history of severe constipation, with an average duration of 7 (2) years. They regularly used oral laxatives or enemas.
Large bowel transit was determined according to the method of Wald.1 ,16 Colonic transit was considered delayed when the residual number of ingested radio-opaque markers visualised in the colon on day 5 after ingestion, was 20% or more of the 50 ingested markers. According to this criterion, all 16 patients had STC. Mean large bowel transit time in the patients was 111 (4) hours.
Twenty healthy volunteers, comprising 15 women and five men with a mean BMI of 22 (0.3) kg/m2 and a mean age of 37 (3) years, served as controls. None of the control subjects was on medication or had a relevant medical history. None of them had a history of constipation or diarrhoea. Stool frequency was once daily. Mean large bowel transit time in the control group was 37 (3) hours.
All subjects gave informed consent and the study protocol was approved by the local human ethics committee. Patients with constipation were instructed to stop any medication interfering with gastrointestinal motility at least three days before the test. They were instructed to defaecate, if necessary with the use of enemas, on the day prior to the measurements.
Gall bladder emptying was studied in response to a cephalic vagal and a hormonal stimulus. The cephalic phase of digestion was induced by modified sham feeding (MSF) according to the “chew and spit” method.17 As the response of the gall bladder to sham feeding is abolished by intravenous atropine or vagotomy,18-20 sham feeding is thought to stimulate through vagal cholinergic neural pathways. In addition, the response of the gall bladder to intravenous infusion with cholecystokinin (CCK) was examined, as this hormone is the most potent hormonal mediator of gall bladder contraction.15
Subjects were studied after an overnight fast and arrived at our department at 8 00 am. Intravenous catheters were inserted into the antecubital veins of both forearms. One cannula was used for blood sampling, the other for hormone infusion. Gall bladder images using ultrasonography were obtained every 15 minutes from time t=−15 to +150 minutes and blood samples for plasma CCK every 30 minutes from time t=−15 and t=0 to +150 minutes. At time t=0 minutes, subjects were offered a standard MSF meal, which consisted of a slice of brown bread, 10 g margarine, a slice of cheese, a slice of meat, 30 g marmalade, and a boiled egg. According to the “chew and spit” technique, subjects were allowed to smell, chew, and taste the items of preference, but were explicitly instructed not to swallow a single morsel of food. After the first 15 minutes subjects were provided with a new, identical MSF meal and the procedure was continued for another 15 minutes until time t=30 minutes. At time t=90 minutes, intravenous infusion with CCK (Ferring Pharmaceuticals, Malmö, Sweden) was started at a rate of 0.5 Ivy Dog Units (IDU) per kilogram body weight per hour. Previous studies have shown that using this dose, plasma CCK concentrations comparable to postprandial concentrations are reached.21 After an hour of CCK infusion, the test was stopped.
GALL BLADDER VOLUMES
Gall bladder volumes measured by real time ultrasonography (Technicare, 3.5 MHz transducer) were calculated by the sum of cylinders method using a computerised system. As previously described, this method divides the longitudinal image of the gall bladder into cylinders of equal height, with diameters perpendicular to the longitudinal axis of the gall bladder image.22 The uncorrected volume is the sum of volumes of these distinct cylinders. A correction factor is calculated from the longitudinal and transversal images of the gall bladder, in order to correct for the displacement of the longitudinal image of the gall bladder from the central axis. By multiplication of the uncorrected volume with the square of the correction factor, the corrected gall bladder volume is calculated.
Absolute (cm3) gall bladder emptying induced by MSF and CCK infusion was calculated by subtracting gall bladder volumes measured at time t=30 and t=150 minutes from gall bladder volumes measured at time t=0 and t=90 minutes respectively. The gall bladder response to MSF was measured at time t=30 minutes as its effect is most pronounced in the first 60 minutes.20 The percentage gall bladder emptying was calculated using the gall bladder volumes at time t=0 and t=90 minutes as reference value (100%).
Immediately after sampling, blood samples were centrifuged for 15 minutes at 3000 rpm at a constant temperature of 4°C. Until CCK concentrations were determined, plasma samples were stored at −20°C. Plasma CCK concentrations were measured by a sensitive and specific radioimmunoassay (RIA) using antibody T204, as described previously.23
Results are expressed as mean (SEM). Statistical comparisons for gall bladder emptying induced by MSF and CCK were made using the non-parametric Wilcoxon rank sum test or, where appropriate, Student’st test for unpaired data. Variations of gall bladder volumes over time were statistically compared by means of analysis of variance (ANOVA). The level of significance was set at p<0.05.
GALL BLADDER EMPTYING
Figure 1 and table 1 depict the results of gall bladder emptying. Mean fasting gall bladder volume, measured at time t=0 minutes, was significantly smaller in the patients with STC than in the controls (figs 1 and 2). In the controls, gall bladder volumes decreased significantly in response to MSF. The reduction in gall bladder volume after MSF in the patients with STC was also statistically significant. Figure 3 depicts individual and mean data of absolute gall bladder emptying in response to MSF. Absolute gall bladder emptying in response to MSF was significantly lower in patients with STC. The percentage gall bladder emptying induced by MSF was also significantly reduced in the patients with STC (table1).
Cholecystokinin induced a significant decrease in gall bladder volume both in controls and in patients. Figure 4 depicts individual data and mean of absolute gall bladder emptying in response to CCK. Absolute gall bladder emptying induced by CCK was significantly reduced in the patient group. However, the percentage volume reduction was not significantly different (table 1). Residual gall bladder volumes at the end of CCK infusion were significantly lower in patients with STC than in controls.
Fasting plasma CCK concentrations were not significantly different between patients (1.7 (0.2) pM) and controls (2.0 (0.1) pM). As expected, during and after MSF, no alterations in plasma CCK were observed. During CCK infusion from time t=90 to t=150 minutes, plasma CCK concentrations increased from 1.7 (0.2) pM to 4.5 (0.2) pM in the patient group, and from 2.0 (0.2) pM to 4.7 (0.3) pM in the control group (NS).
Our results show that gall bladder emptying in patients with STC is different from that in age matched healthy controls.
In patients with STC, mean fasting gall bladder volume was significantly reduced. Several factors are known to influence fasting gall bladder volume. Firstly, CCK is involved not only in the regulation of postprandial gall bladder contraction but also of fasting gall bladder volume. During CCK receptor blockade gall bladder volume increases significantly.24 Fasting plasma CCK concentrations in the patients with STC were not significantly different from those in control subjects, thereby excluding a role for CCK in the smaller fasting gall bladder volumes in these patients. Secondly, the distal gut hormone peptide YY (PYY) induces relaxation of the gall bladder.25 In patients with severe idiopathic constipation reduced plasma PYY concentrations have been found26 and may account for the reduction in fasting gall bladder volume. Thirdly, gall bladder volume is correlated to body mass. A correlation between individual BMI and fasting gall bladder volume has recently been described: a high BMI is correlated with increased basal gall bladder volume.27 However, BMI in our patients with STC was not different from controls. Gall bladder tone is also regulated by vagal cholinergic input. After truncal vagotomy or during vagal cholinergic blockade with atropine, gall bladder volume increases.20 On the other hand, during vagal cholinergic stimulation gall bladder contraction occurs.28 Therefore, the small fasting gall bladder volume of patients with STC might be ascribed to increased vagal tone. However, this is unlikely because recent studies indicate that STC may be associated with autonomic neuropathy.
Indeed, compared with controls, gall bladder contraction in response to MSF was significantly reduced in patients with STC, pointing to impaired vagal cholinergic transmission. Our results are in line with recent findings from Altomare et al 13 who found abnormal results of the acetylcholine sweat spot test in patients with STC, pointing to parasympathetic autonomic neuropathy. Another explanation for the impaired response of the gall bladder to MSF might be alterations of the intramural plexus of the gall bladder, which receives its neuronal input from the vagus nerve. Krishnamurthy et al 29 and Schouten et al 14 have described abnormalities of the colonic myenteric plexus in severe idiopathic constipation. Assuming that in some cases STC might be a systemic disorder, abnormalities of the myenteric plexuses might be more diffusely spread. According to the present study protocol, no differentiation between impaired vagal responsiveness or intrinsic alterations could be made. An increased gall bladder contraction after MSF in the control group was certainly not due to unintentional swallowing of food particles, because plasma CCK did not increase over basal during MSF.
During CCK infusion, gall bladder volumes decreased significantly both in patients and controls. When comparing both groups, the percentage emptying was not different, but the absolute reduction in volume was significantly smaller in patients with STC. Our results partly contrast with findings from two other studies. Neri et al found a stronger gall bladder contraction in patients with STC during intravenous infusion with stepwise increasing doses of the CCK analogue caerulein.30 Another recent study described impaired gall bladder contraction during CCK infusion in patients with STC.31 The discrepancy in results between our study and those of Neri et al and Hemingwayet al may be related to patient selection, measurement techniques (scintigraphy versus ultrasonography), or infusion of CCK (bolus versus continuous) which might result in different plasma CCK concentrations. In the study of Neriet al group size was rather small (n=6), infusion rates of CCK were increased every five minutes, and plasma CCK concentrations were not determined. In the study of Hemingwayet al gall bladder contraction was measured by cholescintigraphy and very high, supraphysiological, doses of CCK were used.
The clinical significance of the present findings is uncertain because we have not evaluated postprandial gall bladder emptying. Apart from neural stimuli and the responsiveness of the gall bladder to CCK, other factors such as the rate of gastric emptying or the amount of endogenous CCK release contribute to postprandial gall bladder emptying.
It is not known whether the incidence of gallstones is higher in patients with STC. Recently an association has been reported between slow intestinal transit and cholesterol gallstones.32Although we did not measure meal stimulated gall bladder emptying in the present study, we showed that the ejection fraction in response to CCK infusion was not altered in patients with STC. In patients with cholesterol gallstones however, postprandial gall bladder emptying is impaired,33 resulting in an increased residual volume. Apart from gall bladder motility, increased biliary deoxycholic acid (DCA), which is associated with increased biliary cholesterol saturation, is also a risk factor for the development of cholesterol gallstones.34 ,35 Secondary to delayed intestinal transit, the circulating bile acid pool might increase in patients with STC, probably resulting in increased biliary DCA concentrations.34 ,36 Increased biliary DCA concentrations secondary to delayed bowel transit may contribute to gallstone disease in these patients. In addition, biliary DCA may directly affect gall bladder motility: long term suppletion of bile acids in gallstone patients for example, increases biliary DCA concentrations and is associated with increased fasting gall bladder volume37 ,38 and with impaired postprandial gall bladder emptying.38-40 Our results point to smaller instead of larger fasting gall bladder volumes in patients with STC, and meal induced gall bladder emptying was not assessed.
In conclusion, gall bladder emptying is affected in patients with STC. Mean fasting gall bladder volume is significantly reduced, as well as the response to a vagal cephalic stimulus, pointing to visceral neuropathy. Our results suggest that apart from the colon, the function of proximal gastrointestinal organs such as the gall bladder is also affected in STC. It is questioned whether these alterations are part of a more generalised intestinal motor disorder.
Abbreviations used in this paper
- body mass index
- deoxycholic acid
- modified sham feeding
- peptide YY
- slow transit constipation
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.