Article Text


Combined suicide and cytokine gene therapy for peritoneal carcinomatosis
  1. C Lechanteura,
  2. P Delvenneb,
  3. F Princena,
  4. M Lopeza,
  5. G Filleta,
  6. J Gielena,
  7. M-P Mervillea,
  8. V Boursa
  1. aLaboratory of Medical Chemistry and Medical Oncology, University of Liège, 4000 Liège, Belgium, bDepartment of Pathology, University of Liège, 4000 Liège, Belgium
  1. V Bours, Medical Oncology, CHU B35, University of Liège, Sart-Tilman 4000 Liège, Belgium. Email: vbours{at}


BACKGROUND Gene therapy is a novel approach for the treatment of cancers, and tumours disseminated in the peritoneal cavity are suitable for in situ delivery of a therapeutic gene.

AIMS The efficacy of a therapy combining a suicide gene (herpes simplex virus type I thymidine kinase (HSV-TK)) and cytokine genes was investigated in a model of peritoneal carcinomatosis induced by colon carcinoma cells in syngeneic rats.

MATERIAL AND METHODS Pre-established macroscopic tumours in BDIX rats were treated by intraperitoneal injections of retrovirus producing cells (FLYA13 TK, FLYA13 granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF), FLYA13 interleukin 12 (IL-12)) and ganciclovir (GCV).

RESULTS TK/GCV treated animals showed a slight increase in survival time (72 days) compared with the control group (63 days) while the association of cytokine and TK/GCV gene therapy resulted in significantly improved survival, with a large proportion of animals remaining tumour free on day 480 (60% and 40% for TK/GCV/GM-CSF and TK/GCV/IL-12 treated animals, respectively). Histological analysis of treated animals showed that the remaining tumour nodes were infiltrated by mononuclear cells but no major differences were observed between the various treatments. Immunohistochemical analysis revealed that lymphoid CD4+and CD8+ T cells as well as macrophages accumulated outside untreated tumour nodes while CD8+ and CD25+activated T cells and macrophages heavily infiltrated the tumours after the different treatments.

CONCLUSIONS Our data indicate that combined suicide and cytokine gene therapy is a powerful approach for the treatment of macroscopic peritoneal carcinomatosis.

  • gene therapy
  • thymidine kinase
  • interleukin 12
  • granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor
  • peritoneal carcinomatosis

Statistics from

Suicide gene therapy is based on the intracellular delivery of a gene coding for an enzyme that transforms a prodrug into a cytotoxic product.1 2 A widely used suicide gene codes for the herpes simplex virus type I thymidine kinase (HSV-TK) which phosphorylates nucleoside analogues such as ganciclovir (GCV) to monophosphate metabolites. Further phosphorylation by endogenous kinases leads to formation of cytotoxic ganciclovir triphosphate.

We previously demonstrated the efficacy of HSV-TK mediated gene therapy for peritoneal carcinomatosis induced by colorectal adenocarcinoma cells in a syngeneic immunocompetent animal model.3 4Other investigators have explored the in vivo antitumour activity of the TK gene5-10 as well as its therapeutic effect in clinical trials.11 However, its efficacy is limited by its low in vivo transduction efficiency. Two approaches can be considered to improve the therapeutic efficacy of a suicide gene. Firstly, new vectors are being developed to increase the efficiency of gene delivery. Secondly, as only a small number of cells are transduced, the bystander effect, a mechanism allowing the killing of untransduced adjacent cells, is crucial and novel strategies are designed to render it more efficient.

Interestingly, a strong bystander effect was observed in our animal model3 and in other experimental systems.6 12 13 Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain this effect, such as the transfer of apoptotic vesicles between adjacent cells or metabolic cooperation through gap junctions. However, several studies have indicated that in vivo, immunity plays an important role in the bystander effect after TK/GCV gene therapy.14

The aim of our study was to boost the bystander effect to achieve longlasting survival and tumour eradication in our model by combined cytokine and TK/GCV gene therapy. Interleukin 12 (IL-12)15-21 and granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF)22-25 are two cytokines that have been used successfully in immunotherapy in different models of established tumours. We chose to use retroviral vectors as such vectors were previously demonstrated to be efficient in our model. Moreover, adenoviral vectors can lead to important inflammatory reactions that could be deleterious in a strategy with repeated injections of vectors delivering cytokine genes. Our results demonstrated that the association of IL-12 or GM-CSF in situ expression with retroviral HSV-TK gene therapy and GCV treatment significantly improved survival rates and the proportion of tumour free survivors.



Eight week old syngeneic BDIX rats were purchased from Iffa-Credo (l'Arbresle, France). DHD/K12 Prob cells, FLYA13 packaging cells, and HSV-TK and BAG retroviral vectors have been described previously.3 4

In the GM-CSF and IL-12 retroviral vectors (MoMuLV), murine GM-CSF or IL-12 p40 and p35genes were placed under the control of the first long terminal repeat and the neomycin resistance gene was driven by an SV-40 promoter. To achieve balanced expression of both the p40 and p35 subunits of mIL-12, we used a bicistronic vector that contains an internal ribosome entry site derived from the encephalomyocarditis virus.

GM-CSF and IL-12 coding sequences were amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) from the pcDNA1 GM-CSF or IL-12 plasmids using Bam HI primers, and PCR products (500 bp) were inserted at the Bam HI site of the BAG retroviral vector instead of the lac Z gene. The pcDNA1 GM-CSF and pcDNA1 IL-12 expression vectors were generous gifts from Professor K Thielemans (Laboratory of Haematology and Immunology, VUB, Brussels, Belgium).

The integrity of the GM-CSF and IL-12 p40 and p35 DNA sequences was confirmed by DNA sequencing.

IL-12 and GM-CSF retroviral vectors were transfected in the FLYA13 packaging cell line by lipofection (DOTAP, Boehringer Mannheim, Germany). Colonies were isolated by G418 selection (geneticin: active concentration 0.5 mg/ml) and expanded.


Secretion of IL-12 and GM-CSF by liposome transfected packaging cells was determined using the Quantiquine ELISA kit (R&D Systems, Wiesbaden, Germany) for detection of murine GM-CSF and the Intertest-12x ELISA kit (Genzyme, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA) for quantification of mouse IL-12 p70. Briefly, 106 transduced cells were plated in 25 cm2 T flasks with 5 ml of culture medium supplemented with G418 (0.5 mg/ml). Forty eight hours later supernatants were centrifuged and tested for mIL-12 or mGM-CSF production by ELISA. Results were expressed in ng/106cells/48 hours.


BDIX rats were injected intraperitoneally on day 0 with 106 DHD/K12 live parental tumour cells. On days 7, 14, and 21, the animals received three intraperitoneal injections of 30×106 retrovirus producing FLYA13-TK cells per animal with or without 20×106 cells producing GM-CSF or IL-12 retroviruses (FLYA13 GM-CSF or FLYA13 IL-12). They were treated with either GCV (150 mg/kg/day) diluted in Hanks' balanced salt solution (HBSS, Life Technologies, Gaithersburg, Maryland, USA) from days 10–13, 17–20, and 24–27 or with HBSS buffer alone according to the same schedule.


Samples of tumours on visceral peritoneum were excised, snap frozen on dry ice using Tissue-Tek and stored at −70°C. Sections (5 μm) were obtained with a cryostat, fixed with carbowax, and stained with haematoxylin-eosin for histological analysis or fixed with cold acetone for 10 minutes and immunostained with specific antibodies for detection of infiltrating cells using the peroxidase method. For this purpose, sections were incubated for 15 minutes in phosphate buffered saline (PBS)/1% bovine serum albumin (BSA) and then overnight at 4°C with monoclonal antibodies diluted in PBS/1% BSA. We used the following antibodies: antimacrophages (ED1, 1/500), anti-CD8 (MRC OX8, 1/100), anti-CD4 (MRC OX35, 1/500), anti-CD25 (MRC OX39, 1/100), and anti-NK/LAK cells (3.2.3., 1/50). These are specific mouse monoclonal antirat antibodies and were purchased from Serotec (Oxford, UK). After washing in PBS, slides were stained with a peroxidase conjugated goat antimouse IgG antibody (Serotec) 1/50 in PBS/1% BSA for 30 minutes at room temperature, washed, and positive cells visualised using diaminobenzidine as the chromogen.


Kaplan-Meyer curves were established for each group and survival rates were compared using the log rank test.



In this study we used the FLYA13 packaging cell line which is known to produce high titres of retroviruses resistant to inactivation by human serum.26 In previous studies we generated an HSV-TK retrovirus producing cell line (FLYA13 TK).4 Two other cell lines were generated (FLYA13 IL-12 and FLYA13 GM-CSF) by transfection of a retroviral vector (MoMuLV-derived) containing IL-12 p40 and p35 or GM-CSF cDNAs, respectively. After G418 selection, we measured the number of retroviral particles produced by the different cell lines and reproducibly found a titre of 2×105 plaque forming units (pfu)/ml for FLYA13 TK cells, 104 pfu/ml for FLYA13 IL-12 cells, and 105 pfu/ml for FLYA13 GM-CSF cells.

The FLYA13 IL-12 and FLYA13 GM-CSF retrovirus producing cell lines were also analysed for cytokine expression. FLYA13 IL-12 cells produced 60 ng of IL-12/106 cells/48 hours and FLYA13 GM-CSF cells 30 ng of GM-CSF/106 cells/48 hours (data not shown).


We investigated the efficiency of HSV-TK gene therapy combined with cytokine gene therapy in a model of peritoneal carcinomatosis induced by DHD/K12 colorectal adenocarcinoma cells in syngeneic BDIX rats. BDIX rats were injected intraperitoneally on day 0 with 106 DHD/K12 cells and received three intraperitoneal injections of retrovirus producing FLYA13 TK cells on days 7, 14, and 21 with or without FLYA13 IL-12 or FLYA13 GM-CSF cells. Rats were treated with GCV (150 mg/kg/day) from days 10–13, 17–20, and 24–27. Control animals were injected with FLYA13 TK cells and treated with HBSS buffer alone according to the same schedule as the GCV treated group (fig 1A).

Figure 1

Tumour response after gene therapy with thymidine kinase/ganciclovir (TK/GCV) plus cytokines. Rats injected with DHD/K12 cells received three intraperitoneal injections of herpes simplex virus type I thymidine kinase (HSV-TK) retrovirus producing FLYA13 TK cells together with cytokine retrovirus producing FLYA13 granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF) or FLYA13 interleukin 12 (IL-12) cells. Each injection was followed by treatment with GCV or Hanks' balanced salt solution (HBSS). (Top) Protocol for intraperitoneal delivery of retrovirus producing cells and GCV treatment. Each group (six animals/group) was injected intraperitoneally with 106DHD/K12 cells on day 0. The HSV-TK, GM-CSF, and IL-12 producing cells FLYA13 TK, FLYA13 GM-CSF, and FLYA13 IL-12 were injected intraperitoneally on days 7, 14, and 21. For the GCV treated groups, the first treatment was administered from days 10–13, the second from days 17–20, and the third from days 24–27. Treatment comprised 150 mg/kg of GCV once a day. At the same time, the control group received 10 ml of HBSS once daily. (Bottom) Animals were killed on day 30 and a representative picture of the peritoneal cavity is shown: (A) control rat, (B) rat treated with TK/GCV, (C) rat treated with TK/GCV/IL-12, and (D) rat treated with TK/GCV/GM-CSF.

At the end of the protocol (day 30), one animal from each group was killed and peritoneal dissemination of the tumour was assessed by direct abdominal examination (fig 1B). The peritoneal cavity of the control animal was completely invaded by tumour nodes (fig 1A) while the TK/GCV treated animal showed a highly reduced tumour burden (fig1B). Combined therapies (TK/GCV/IL-12 (fig 1C) or TK/GCV/GM-CSF (fig1D)) resulted in further tumour regression with virtually no visible tumour.

Five animals from each group were monitored and survival curves were established. Control HBSS treated animals died between days 48 and 77 (median survival 63 days) while rats injected with the FLYA13 TK retrovirus producing cells and treated with GCV died between days 54 and 136 (median survival 72 days), thus showing an increased survival time (fig 2). In this experiment, the survival difference failed to reach significance (log rank test p=0.1).

Figure 2

Survival of rats treated with thymidine kinase/ganciclovir (TK/GCV) and cytokine genes. Five animals from each group were monitored until they died. In the group who received herpes simplex virus type I thymidine kinase (HSV-TK) and granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF) producing FLYA13 cells, three of five animals were still alive and tumour free on day 480 while two of five animals were still alive at the same time in the HSV-TK/interleukin 12 (IL-12) group. HBSS, Hanks' balanced salt solution.

However, the combination of cytokine gene therapy and HSV-TK/GCV gene therapy resulted in significantly improved survival rates (log rank test p<0.05) with a large proportion of animals remaining tumour free. Indeed, 60% of animals treated with FLYA13 TK/GCV in combination with FLYA13 GM-CSF and 40% of animals treated with FLYA13 TK/GCV and FLYA13 IL-12 were still alive on day 480 (fig 2).


Standard histology of untreated tumours has been described previously.27 Briefly, haematoxylin-eosin stained sections of the tumour tissues, harvested on days 14, 21, and 27, revealed sheets or nodules of poorly differentiated epithelial cells surrounded by a fibrous stroma with a focally extensive desmoplastic reaction. Mononuclear cells with scattered eosinophilic granulocytes were also found interspersed between the tumour nodules (fig 3A). In treated rats, the main difference was replacement of some or, in some cases, all cancer nodules by an extensive mononuclear cell infiltrate. These inflammatory cells were observed around necrotic or tumour areas but were also found to infiltrate these areas (fig 3B). No major changes in these histological features were observed between the different treatments.

Figure 3

Standard histology of the tumours. Haematoxylin-eosin staining of intraperitoneal tumours from (A) control (100× magnification) or (B, C) treated animals (100× and 200× magnification, respectively).

Immunohistological analysis of untreated tumours showed that lymphoid CD4+ and CD8+ T cells as well as macrophages accumulated outside the tumour nodes (fig 4, table 1). After TK/GCV gene therapy, the tumours were heavily infiltrated by CD8+cytotoxic T cells and macrophages (fig 4, table 1). We did not observe any significant difference after treatment with TK/GCV in combination with IL-12 or GM-CSF compared with TK/GCV alone regarding CD8+ T cell or macrophage infiltration. However, the number of CD25+ activated T cells infiltrating the tumour was higher after combined therapies (table1).

Figure 4

Immunohistochemical staining using anti-CD8+ (1), antimacrophage (2), anti-CD25+(3), or anti-NK cell (4) antibodies on frozen sections of tumours from control (left) or treated (right) animals (250× magnification).

Table 1

Immunostaining of lymphoid and macrophagic cells infiltrating the tumours after thymidine kinase/ganciclovir (TK/GCV) or combined TK/GCV/interleukin 12 (IL-12) or TK/GCV/granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF) treatments. Shown are the average scores after immunostaining with the different antibodies (arbitrary scale graded from − to +++). In each case, control untreated animals were compared with animals that had received one (day 14), two (day 21), or three (day 27) courses of retrovirus producing cells plus GCV. In treated animals, few biopsies showed any residual tumours and the proportion of tumour free biopsies for each condition is indicated in the first column. Results are given separately for the tumour (T) itself and the stroma (S) corresponding to the corona of inflammatory cells surrounding the tumour


Peritoneal carcinomatosis remains a major clinical problem as neither surgery nor chemotherapy can eradicate these tumours. Thus novel therapeutic approaches are required to treat these cancers which may constitute a suitable model for gene therapy.

We previously demonstrated that three injections of retrovirus producing FLYA13 TK cells followed by GCV treatment significantly increased the survival rate of rats bearing extensive DHD/K12 derived peritoneal carcinomatosis.4 Nevertheless, very few treated animals remained tumour free (10%), confirming that the TK gene alone rarely eradicates established solid tumours.4 6

One way of improving HSV-TK gene therapy is to boost the bystander effect. Several studies have reported that the immune system participates in the bystander effect following TK/GCV gene therapy.28-33 For example, several groups highlighted the failure of immunodeficient or sublethally irradiated mice to reject HSV-TK transfected tumours after GCV treatment, indicating that the bystander effect relies in part on an intact immune system.32 33 Therefore, if HSV-TK/GCV treatment depends on the development of an antitumour immune response to achieve long term remission, its success should be improved by concomitant stimulation of the immune system. As antigens are released after HSV-TK/GCV gene therapy, simultaneous local expression of appropriate cytokines could initiate such an effect.34 35 Indeed, a few studies have demonstrated that the efficacy of TK/GCV gene therapy is improved by simultaneous administration of the IL-2 gene or by a combination of the IL-2 and GM-CSF genes.36-38

In the present study, when FLYA13 IL-12 or FLYA13 GM-CSF cells were combined with FLYA13 TK cells, a highly significant increase in survival was observed. Moreover, 60% and 40% of TK/GM-CSF and TK/IL-12 treated rats, respectively, were apparently free of tumour on day 480 and could be considered as cured.

HSV-TK/GCV gene therapy leads to necrosis in several tumour models.30 33 Tumour antigens are thus available to the immune system and may activate an antitumour immune response through uptake and presentation by antigen presenting cells (APC). GM-CSF is known to induce APC differentiation and may promote maturation of APC previously attracted to the tumour site by TK/GCV treatment, rendering them more effective.

In contrast, several groups have previously described a Th1 immune response after HSV-TK/GCV therapies in different models.29IL-12 is a proinflammatory cytokine which enhances CD8+ T cell cytolytic activity and supports the differentiation of Th1 helper CD4+ T cells. In situ production of IL-12 may enhance this Th1 immune response pathway, generating cytotoxic CD8+ T cells.

Indeed, co-expression of GM-CSF or IL-12 with the TK gene led to improved survival in our model, suggesting that a better antigen presentation or a more efficient Th 1 response could improve TK therapeutic activity. Tumour infiltration by CD8+ T cells and macrophages after TK/GCV gene therapy confirms that such a treatment induces an immune response, as previously suggested by several studies; however, we did not observe significant differences in the immune infiltrates generated by the three therapeutic strategies. But although the number of infiltrating lymphoid or macrophagic cells remained approximately equivalent, animals treated with cytokine genes in addition to TK/GCV probably developed a more effective antitumour immune response.

Our data confirm that an immune reaction is associated with TK/GCV gene therapy and indicate that a strategy combining a suicide gene and cytokine genes may be a way of improving the results of gene therapy. Interestingly, boosting the immune response may also have an effect on lesions away from the injected tumour, such as micrometastases. Indeed, several observations indicate that, under certain experimental conditions, suicide gene therapy can induce a systemic immune response, capable of mediating regression of distant metastases after eradication of a localised cytosine deaminase or thymidine kinase expressing tumour.39 40

In conclusion, our data confirm that suicide genes have only a limited efficacy and that their antitumour activity may be increased by simultaneous expression of cytokine genes. Clinical trials should be considered with combined therapies.


We thank Dr C-M. Calberg for the TK retroviral vector and Professor K Thielemans (VUB, Brussels, Belgium) for the GM-CSF and IL-12 genes. We thank L-M Dupuis and C Hauglustaine for technical assistance and J-P Cheramibien for excellent help with the animals. PD and M-PM are research associates and VB is a senior research associate at the National Fund for Scientific Research (Belgium). FP is supported by a FRIA fellowship. This research was supported by grants from the “Centre Anti-Cancéreux” (Liège, Belgium) and from the “Concerted Action Program, Convention 97/02–214”, Communauté Française de Belgique.


View Abstract


  • Abbreviations used in this paper:
    thymidine kinase
    herpes simplex virus
    interleukin 12
    granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor
    Hanks' balanced salt solution
    polymerase chain reaction
    phosphate buffered saline
    bovine serum albumin
    antigen presenting cells
    plaque forming units

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Linked Articles