Article Text

Download PDFPDF

High incidence of adenocarcinoma arising from the right side of the gastric cardia in NW Iran
  1. M H Derakhshan1,
  2. A Yazdanbod2,
  3. A R Sadjadi1,
  4. B Shokoohi2,
  5. K E L McColl3,
  6. R Malekzadeh1
  1. 1Digestive Disease Research Centre, Shariati Hospital, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
  2. 2Department of Medicine and Pathology, Ardabil University of Medical Sciences, Ardabil, Iran
  3. 3Section of Medicine, Western Infirmary, Glasgow, UK
  1. Correspondence to:
    Professor R Malekzadeh
    Digestive Disease Research Centre, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Shariati Hospital, North Kargar Ave, 14114 Tehran, Iran;


Background: In the West, the subsite incidence of gastric cancer has changed in recent decades, with cancer of the cardia increasing in incidence and that of the more distal stomach decreasing. NW Iran has a very high incidence of upper gastrointestinal cancer and we have examined the anatomical site specific incidence in this geographical region.

Method and materials: Of 33 718 patients who visited our clinic from March 2000 to Jan 2003, 3119 (9.3%) with persistent upper gastrointestinal symptoms underwent upper gastrointestinal fibreoptic endoscopy. Exact tumour site, subsite, and axial view were determined. Demographic data including age, sex, and place of residence were assessed. Using matched data from the cancer registry and endoscopic survey, age standardised rates (ASR) for all subsites were calculated.

Results: Upper gastrointestinal cancer was diagnosed histologically in 499 patients (16.0%). The most frequent site was the gastric cardia (126 (25.3%)) followed by the oesophageal body (90 (18.0%)), antrum (82 (16.4%)), corpus (74 (14.8%)), distal oesophagus (57 (11.4%)), gastro-oesophageal junction (47 (9.4%)), and proximal oesophagus (22 (4.4%)). From axial views of the cardia, 51.4% and 6.8% of tumours were found to originate from the lesser and greater curve, respectively. ASR for gastric cancer were 51.2 in males and 15.4 in females. Cardia cancer with ASR of 26.4 in males and 8.6 in females was the major component of gastric cancer.

Conclusion: NW Iran is a geographical region with a very high incidence of cardia cancer and with the great majority originating from the right side of the cardia. This suggests a locally acting luminal carcinogen. Studying the aetiology of this cancer in NW Iran is likely to increase our understanding of the rising incidence of this cancer throughout the Western world.

  • ASR, age standardised rate
  • gastric cancer
  • cardia cancer
  • Ardabil
  • Iran

Statistics from

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Gastric cancer remains the world’s third most common malignancy.1 However, in the West, there have been marked changes in the incidence of cancer at different anatomical subsites of the stomach. Adenocarcinoma of the most proximal cardia region of the stomach and adjacent gastro-oesophageal junction has increased in incidence over the past 25 years and at a rate which exceeds that of any other cancer.2–4 In contrast, adenocarcinoma of the more distal stomach (non-cardia cancer) has been progressively falling in incidence for at least the last 50 years.5 In Japan, the incidence of gastric cancer is particularly high, and 90% are located distal to the cardia.6

These opposing incidence trends indicate distinct aetiologies for these cancer of the two subsites of the stomach. Consistent with this, cancers at these subsites also differ with respect to the underlying gastric phenotype against which the cancer develops. Non-cardia gastric cancer occurs in patients with Helicobacter pylori induced atrophic gastritis and accompanying hypochlorhydria.7,8 In contrast, cancer of the cardia and gastro-oesophageal junction occurs in subjects with normal acid secreting stomachs and is not associated with H pylori infection.7,9,10

The fall in incidence of non-cardia gastric cancer in the western world may be explained by the decrease in incidence of H pylori infection and associated atrophic gastritis and hypochlorhydria. However, the cause of the rising incidence of cancer of the cardia region of the stomach and gastro-oesophageal junction is unknown. Gastro-oesophageal reflux may be involved in the aetiology of adenocarcinoma within the oesophagus as there is an association between the two conditions.11 However, there is little association between cardia cancer and reflux disease, and its aetiology remains unclear.11

Gastric cancer is the most common malignancy in Iran and its incidence is particularly high in the Ardabil province in the north west of the country.12–16 In this province, the age standard incidence rate is 49.1 and 25.4 per 100 000 persons per year in males and females, respectively. The cause of the high incidence of gastric cancer in this geographical region is unknown. In view of the recent recognition that the different anatomical subsites of gastric cancer have different aetiologies, we have performed a detailed analysis of the distribution and subsite incidence of upper gastrointestinal cancer in this geographical region.


Endoscopic survey

This prospective study was conducted in the first established subspecialty outpatient gastrointestinal clinic in Ardabil City. Of the 33 718 patients who attended this clinic with a chief complain of upper gastrointestinal symptoms over a 33 month period (March 2000–January 2003), 3119 patients (9.3%) who were older than 45 year age or were found to have at least one alarming gastrointestinal sign or symptom (dysphagia, persistent abdominal pain, weight loss, anaemia, abdominal mass, persistent vomiting) were enrolled. Using 10% lidocaine spray in the pharynx, standard upper gastrointestinal endoscopy was performed. According to WHO/IARC guidelines for classification of adenocarcinoma of the gastro-oesophageal junction area, the following definitions were used for exact localisation of tumours17:

  • Adenocarcinoma of gastro-oesophageal junction: when a tumour crosses the gastro-oesophageal junction regardless of the site of the tumour bulk.

  • Adenocarcinoma of oesophagus: when the tumour is entirely above the gastro-oesophageal junction.

  • Adenocarcinoma of gastric cardia: when the tumour is entirely below the gastro-oesophageal junction, centred within 2 cm distal to the junction.

According to observed and portrayed lesions on endoscopy sheets, we considered the cardia at endoscopy as two right and left semicircles. The right semicircle was located just at the continuity or direction of the lesser curvature. The left semicircle was located just at the continuity of the fundal area and greater curvature. By definition, tumours which were more than 80% within the right semicircle were named right sided lesions. For the left side, the same definition was used. The oesophagus was carefully scrutinised for location of the gastro-oesophageal junction and Z-line. Location of tumours was registered accurately and at least six punch biopsies were obtained from all tumours. Biopsy specimens were oriented, fixed in 10% buffered formalin, sectioned, and stained using the haematoxylin-eosin technique. Experienced pathologists then examined the specimens for evidence of cancer.

Studies were undertaken to validate the endoscopic localisation of the junction tumours. This was performed in patients who underwent surgery by comparing surgical and gross pathological descriptions of the site of the tumour with those recorded at endoscopy.

Comparing estimated incidence rates

Data from the Ardabil Cancer Registry (ACR) did not have sufficient information on subsite distribution of upper gastrointestinal tumours; only cases registered at Yazdanbod Clinic had endoscopic localisation of tumours. Therefore, we used these patients as incident cases. For definition of the population at risk, all residents of areas covered by this clinic were included in the census. This population was approximately 48% of the entire province population and was 560 608 persons at the midpoint of the study interval. To best compare our data with those of the Scottish Cancer Registry, oesophageal tumours were divided into two histological categories (squamous cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma), and all adenocarcinomas of the stomach were classified as cardia or non-cardia cancer. Results are minimal rates and approximate estimates from clinic based data, and cannot be attributed exactly to population based registry systems. All estimates are presented as age standardised rates (ASR); the reference population for standardisation was the World Standard Population.18 Age groups in the reference population are presented in five year categories but we categorised our age groups into10 year intervals. We used a direct method for standardisation.19


During the period of study, 523 cases of suspected upper gastrointestinal tract cancer were found endoscopically and a diagnosis of cancer was confirmed by histopathology of the endoscopic biopsies in 493 of these cases. Pathological confirmation was also available for an additional six surgically resected tumours, thus making a total of 499 upper gastrointestinal cancers. Mean age of all patients was 63.2 (10.6) years and the male to female ratio was 2.2:1.

Subsite distribution

Of these 499 gastro-oesophageal cancer cases, 169 (33.9%) were in the oesophagus, 282 (56.5%) in the stomach, 47 (9.4%) at the gastro-oesophageal junction, and one (0.2 %) at a gastrojejunostomy stoma. Of the oesophageal cancers, 22 (13.0%), 90 (53.3%), and 57 (33.7%) were at the upper, middle, and lower thirds of the oesophagus, respectively. Of the stomach cancers, 126 (43.7%) were located in the cardia region. The antrum and body region of the stomach were the second and third most common sites, with 82 (29.1%) and 74 (26.2%) cases, respectively (table 1).

Table 1

 Topography and histology of upper gastrointestinal tumours

Overall, 46 %(230/499) of all tumours and 54% (187/345) of adenocarcinomas of the upper gastrointestinal tract originated from near the gastro-oesophageal junction involving the lower oesophagus, gastro-oesophageal junction, or gastric cardia. As shown in (table 2), 41.7% of cardia cancers were circumferential, 51.4% located at the right side, and 6.8% at the left side. Therefore, 88% (53/60) of early cardia cancers were seen to originate from the right side. Circumferential tumours were more frequent at the gastro-oesophageal junction and distal oesophagus, being 63.4% and 70.8%, respectively.

Table 2

 Endoscopic localisation of malignant tumours of the junctional area

Only 99 of 178 patients with cancers arising near to the gastro-oesophageal junction underwent surgical intervention and had a reliable surgical and pathological topographic report. Of the 59 cardia cancers, 40 (68%) were on the right side, six (10%) on the left side, and 13 (22%) circumferential (table 3). The propensity for the cardia cancers to arise from the right side was thus confirmed.

Table 3

 Surgical localisation of malignant tumours of the junctional area


A total of 345 (69.1%) upper gastrointestinal tumours were adenocarcinomas, 148 (29.7%) squamous cell carcinomas, four (0.8%) malignant lymphomas, and two (0.4%) carcinoid tumours. Except for one case of carcinoid tumour, almost all (99.2%) cancers of the cardia were adenocarcinomas. Based on the Lauren classification of adenocarcinomas, 48.0% of the cardia cancers were of the intestinal-type, 35.2% diffuse-type (p<0.05), and 16.8% undeterminable (table 4). At the distal oesophagus, 20 (35.1%) tumours were adenocarcinomas and 37 (64.9%) were squamous cell carcinomas. At the gastro-oesophageal junction, only five (10.6%) tumours were squamous cell carcinomas and the remaining 89.4% were adenocarcinomas. Mean age of all patients with adenocarcinoma were significantly higher than those with squamous cell carcinoma (64.3 (10.4) v 60.9 (10.8); p<0.05). Also, mean age of patients with intestinal-type adenocarcinomas (65.8 (8.7)), was higher than patients with diffuse-type adenocarcinoma (62.1 (10.8)) (p<0.05).

Table 4

 Type of adenocarcinoma according to the Lauren classification

Estimated incidence rates

Crude incidence rates for all upper gastrointestinal tumours were 43.7 per 100 000 per year in males and 20.1 per 100 000 per year in females. ASR of all upper gastrointestinal tumours in males and females were 69.1/100 000/year and 36.4/100 000/year, respectively.

ASR of gastric cancer were 51.2 in males and 15.4 in females. Cardia cancer, with ASR of 26.4 in males and 8.6 in females, was the major component of gastric cancer. Cancer of the cardia was the most common upper gastrointestinal malignancy in males but in females oesophageal squamous cell carcinoma with an ASR of 17.8 was more common. Irrespective of sex differences, adenocarcinoma of the cardia and oesophageal squamous cell carcinoma were the first and second incident upper gastrointestinal malignancies in Ardabil.


The youngest patient was a 22 year male with diffuse-type adenocarcinoma of the gastric corpus and the oldest was a 90 year old male with intestinal-type adenocarcinoma of the cardia. Patients with upper oesophageal tumour had the lowest mean age (58.9 (10.7)) and patients with gastric corpus tumour had the highest mean age (66.4 (9.8) years). Mean age of cardia cancer patients was 64.2 (9.1) years. With the exception of mean age in antral cancer patients, we observed an increasing trend in age from proximal to distal tumour sites. Patients with right sided gastric cardia cancer had a lower age than those with left sided cancer (65.2 (9.1) v 69.3 (5.8); p<0.05).

Place of residence Living place

A total of 344 (70.2%) and 146 (29.8%) patients lived in rural and urban areas, respectively. Place of residence had no effect on the frequency of cardia cancer but comparing gastric cancer as a whole versus oesophageal cancer, urban dwellers had a greater risk of having gastric cancer than rural dweller (odds ratio 1.77 (95% confidence interval 1.2–2.7)).


This study indicates that a high proportion of gastro-oesophageal cancers diagnosed in this geographical region occur at the cardia region of the stomach; 24.6% of all cancers and 36.2% of adenocarcinomas occurring throughout the oesophagus or stomach occurred at this anatomical site. More cancers occurred at the cardia than at any other anatomical subsite. This is consistent with earlier observations.16

The high proportion of cancers occurring at the cardia could be due to a high incidence of cancer at this site or, alternatively, a low incidence of cancer in other regions of the upper gastrointestinal tract. We therefore assessed the incidence of cancer to allow comparison with values reported from other world regions. The ASR of gastric cancer, irrespective of anatomical subsite, in the Ardabil region was 51.2 in males and 15.4 in females. This incidence rate is high compared with other countries and within the top quintile of reported incidences.20 Less data are available on the actual incidence of cancer of the gastric cardia in different countries. However, the incidence in the Ardabil region is substantially higher than available reports from 10 European countries,21–23 the USA,2 Japan,6 and Korea.24 Detailed subsite incidence rates are available for Scotland, which also has a high incidence of upper gastrointestinal cancer.25 However, cardia cancer ASR in NW Iran is more than six times that of Scotland (table 5). We therefore conclude that the large proportion of cancers occurring at the cardia region of the stomach in this geographical area reflects a particularly high incidence of cancer at this anatomical location.

Table 5

 Upper gastrointestinal cancer incidence from the Scottish Cancer Registry 1999 compared with the results of our study

In view of the recent recognition of the importance of cancer subsite to aetiology, we examined the location of the cardia cancer in more detail. This indicated that there was a clear propensity for cardia cancers to arise from the right side (that is, lesser curve) rather than from the left side (or greater curvature). As far as we are aware, this is the first study to document the radial distribution of cardia cancer.

Another geographical region with a very high incidence of cardia cancer is the Linxian region of China.26 Professor Guo-Qing Wang of the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences has vast experience in endoscopic diagnosis and surgical resection of cardia cancer in China. In a personal communication, he informed us that more than 85% of early cancers of the cardia are found on the right side.

The cardia represents a relatively small region of the stomach with a surface area of only 5–10% of the entire stomach. The small area of the cardia means that its cancer incidence expressed as per unit of epithelial surface area is extremely high. This high local incidence increases further when one considers that most are occurring on the right side of the cardia.

What is the explanation for the high incidence of cancers originating at the right side of the gastric cardia? This is an important question as it should provide insight into the aetiology of the cancer. Previous studies have indicated lack of a positive association between H pylori infection and cancer of the gastric cardia.27 However, it is possible that there are geographical differences in the association between H pylori and cardia cancer as some Western countries found a negative association28 and a Chinese study a positive association.26 Studies have shown little association between reflux disease and cancer at this anatomical site.11 The Ardabil region has a high incidence of H pylori infection (>80%) and a substantial incidence of reflux disease.29 In addition, 30% smoke, less than 5% drink alcohol, and 60% have a body mass index greater than 25.29 However, none of these can adequately account for the high incidence of cardia cancer.

It is generally recognised that epithelial cancers are a result of luminal factors. Therefore, luminal factors acting maximally at the cardia and particularly at its right side have to be considered. The gastric cardia is where ingested material and swallowed saliva first enters the stomach. It has also been shown that on entering the stomach, non-solid material proceeds down the lesser curve (that is, right side) following the “Magenstrasse” or “canalis gastricus” formed by the longitudinal mucosal folds.30 The right side of the cardia will therefore have particularly high exposure to carcinogens or precarcinogens in swallowed liquid or saliva. Interestingly, the lesser curve has previously been recognised as the region of the stomach with the highest incidence of incomplete metaplasia.31

The Ardabil region is characterised by a high incidence of cancer throughout the upper gastrointestinal tract, including squamous cell carcinoma of the oesophagus, adenocarcinoma of the distal stomach, as well as a particularly high incidence of adenocarcinoma of the cardia.32 This would be consistent with high exposure to a luminal carcinogen exerting its effects throughout this anatomical region and with a predilection for the gastric cardia. Regions of China with a very high incidence of cardia adenocarcinoma also have a high incidence of oesophageal squamous cell carcinoma, again implicating a swallowed carcinogen.26,33

Several studies have recently reported that the luminal chemistry of the cardia region is distinct from that of the rest of the stomach or oesophagus. Ingestion of food increases the pH of most of the stomach due to the buffering effect of the protein but the cardia region remains acidic and this acid pocket facilitates chemical reactions occurring at low pH.34 The potential for generation of N-nitroso compounds from dietary nitrate in the acid secreting stomach is also maximal at the cardia region.35 Following its absorption, 25% of circulating nitrate is taken up by salivary glands and secreted into the mouth where it is reduced to nitrite by buccal bacteria.36,37 This salivary nitrite derived from enterosalivary recirculation of nitrate is the main source of nitrite entering the human stomach. On encountering the acidic pH of the stomach, nitrite is rapidly converted to nitrous acid and nitrosating species which can react with nitrosatable compounds to form potentially carcinogenic N-nitroso compounds.38 Acidification of salivary nitrite also generates very high concentrations of nitric oxide which again are maximal in the cardia regions.39,40 High concentrations of nitric oxide are also thought to be mutagenic.41–46 Being a non-solid substance, saliva will follow the lesser curve on entering the stomach.31 The Ardabil region is at the foot of a volcano, called Sabalan, and soil nitrate content is being investigated.

The incidence of cardia cancer in the Ardabil region of NW Iran is the highest recorded anywhere in the world and this provides a unique opportunity to investigate its aetiology. Our observation that the tumour usually originates from the right side of the cardia provides an intriguing clue. Elucidating the aetiology of cardia cancer is of great importance due to its rising incidence throughout the world.