Background Pneumatic balloon dilatation (PD) is a regular treatment modality for achalasia. The reported success rates of PD vary. Recurrent symptoms often require repeated PD or surgery.
Objective To identify predicting factors for symptom recurrence requiring repeated treatment.
Methods Between 1974 and 2006, 336 patients were treated with PD and included in this longitudinal cohort study. The median follow-up was 129 months (range 1–378). Recurrence of achalasia was defined as symptom recurrence in combination with increased lower oesophageal sphincter (LOS) pressure on manometry, requiring repeated treatment. Patient characteristics, results of timed barium oesophagram and manometry as well as baseline PD characteristics were evaluated as predictors of disease recurrence with Kaplan–Meier curves and Cox regression analysis.
Results 111 patients had symptom recurrence requiring repeated treatment. Symptoms recurred after a mean follow-up of 51 months (range 1–348). High recurrence percentages were found in patients younger than 21 years in whom the 5 and 10-year risks of recurrence were 64% and 72%, respectively. These risks were respectively 28% and 36% in patients with classic achalasia, respectively 48% and 60% in patients without complete obliteration of the balloon's waist during PD and respectively 25% and 33% in patients with a LOS pressure greater than 10 mm Hg at 3 months post-dilatation. These four predictors remained statistically significant in a multivariable Cox analysis.
Conclusion Although PD is an effective primary treatment in patients with primary achalasia, patients are at risk of recurrent disease, with this risk increasing during long-term follow-up. Young age at presentation, classic achalasia, high LOS pressure 3 months after PD and incomplete obliteration of the balloon's waist during PD are the most important predicting factors for the need for repeated treatment during follow-up. Patients who meet one or more of these characteristics may be considered earlier for alternative treatment, such as surgery.
- pneumatic balloon dilatation
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial License, which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non commercial and is otherwise in compliance with the license. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0/ and http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0/legalcode.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Significance of this study
What is already known about this subject?
Several studies have reported success rates of PD between 35% and 85%.
The previous identified risk factors for symptom recurrence after PD were mainly young age (<40 years), a post-treatment LOS pressure above 10 mm Hg and a short period of symptoms before treatment.
Laparoscopic myotomy combined with an antireflux procedure provides better symptom relief than all endoscopic and other surgical approaches, with a low complication rate.
What are the new findings?
After treatment with PD we found a 5-year risk of recurrence of 28%.
Given the long follow-up period in our study, we were able to show that the rate of recurrence does increase over time.
Young age at presentation, a manometric pattern of classic achalasia, high LOS pressure 3 months after PD, and incomplete obliteration of the balloon''s waist during PD are the most important predicting factors for the need for repeated treatment during follow-up.
How might it impact on clinical practice in the foreseeable future?
This implies that a stricter follow-up can be given to patients with the above-mentioned predicting factors, as the chance of recurrence is significantly higher in this subgroup. Using a stricter follow-up, recurrence (defined as symptom recurrence in combination with objective parameters such as a significant increase in LOS pressure) can be diagnosed at an earlier stage.
Patients who meet one or more of these characteristics may be considered earlier for alternative treatment, such as surgery.
Achalasia is a rare condition, with an estimated annual incidence of one per 100 000, characterised by a functional obstruction of the oesophagus caused by failed relaxation of the lower oesophageal sphincter (LOS) in combination with absent peristalsis of the distal oesophagus.1 The aetiology of achalasia is still unknown. The disease is characterised by a loss of inhibitory nitrinergic neurons in the oesophageal myenteric plexus. Proposed causes include genetic inheritance, neuronal degeneration, viral infection and autoimmune disease.2 The characteristic symptoms of patients with achalasia are dysphagia for solids and liquids, regurgitation of undigested food or saliva, respiratory complaints (nocturnal cough, aspiration), retrosternal pain and weight loss. Therapeutic options aim to improve oesophageal emptying by decreasing LOS pressure. There are several treatment options, either endoscopic (botulinum toxin injection and pneumatic balloon dilatation (PD)) or surgical.3 Most gastroenterologists prefer PD as first-line therapy. Nevertheless, the reported success rates of PD vary widely, ranging in previous studies from 35% to 85% within several years of follow-up.4–11 These marked differences may be partly explained by differences in the length of follow-up. Recurrence of symptoms often requires repeated PD or further treatment with surgery. The major determinants for PD therapy failure are insufficiently known; such knowledge would be clinically relevant as it may aid in targeted surveillance and early intervention in high-risk groups. Several studies have therefore tried to identify predicting factors of clinical outcome following PD. Some did not find any specific predictor.10 Other studies found that advanced age, female gender, a long history of symptoms before diagnosis, high pre-therapeutic LOS pressure, a post-dilatation LOS pressure of less than 10 mm Hg, limited contrast retention on barium oesophagram post-dilatation and a higher number of repeated baseline PD dilatations were associated with a favourable treatment outcome.5 6 8 11–15 These studies were often performed with relatively small groups of patients. The aim of this study was therefore to identify predicting factors for symptom recurrence requiring repeated PD in a large cohort of patients with primary achalasia.
Patients and methods
From 1974 to 2006, 433 patients (214 men and 219 women), mean age 51.1±21.6 years (range 4–92) were diagnosed with primary achalasia in our centre. Their data were prospectively included in a database, and they were treated and followed according to a strict patient management, treatment and follow-up protocol, which remained unchanged throughout the study period.
The diagnosis of achalasia was based on results from gastroscopy, manometry and timed barium oesophagram.
Upper gastrointestinal endoscopy using a fibre or video-endoscope (Olympus Europe, Hamburg, Germany) was performed to rule out secondary achalasia.
Oesophageal manometry was performed using a low compliance, pneumohydraulic water infusion system (Medical Measure Systems, Enschede, The Netherlands) and a four-channel silicone catheter (Medical Measure Systems). From May 2005 onwards we used an eight-channel water-perfused manometry assembly with an incorporated 6 cm long reversed-perfused sleeve sensor (Dentsleeve International Ltd, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada). The recording sites were connected to an eight-channel polygraph (Medical Measure Systems). The four-channel catheter was introduced with all four recording sites in the stomach and then manually pulled back per centimetre with a wet swallow of 5 cc water at each centimetre. The eight-channel catheter was introduced in the stomach and then manually pulled back till the sleeve was positioned at the level of the LOS. Mean resting LOS pressure was calculated as the mean end-expiratory LOS pressure during 10 wet swallows. LOS relaxations were considered to be absent if no change was recorded after swallowing and complete if swallow-induced LOS pressure returned to the basic intragastric level. A pressure fall above basic gastric level was considered as partial relaxation. Peristaltic wave amplitudes were also calculated as mean wave amplitudes during 10 wet swallows. Aperistalsis was diagnosed if all contractions after swallowing were simultaneous. We differentiated two patterns of aperistalsis. Classic achalasia was defined with the presence of non-transmitted or simultaneous contractions with a low amplitude. Vigorous achalasia was diagnosed if there were simultaneous contractions with an amplitude of more than 37 mm Hg.
Timed barium oesophagram
Timed barium swallow was performed in the standing position after an overnight fast. The patient was asked to drink 200 cc barium solution (or as much as tolerated without regurgitation or aspiration) and recordings of the oesophagus were performed at 0, 1 and 10 min after the last barium swallow. The appearance of a so-called ‘bird's beak’ was recorded, and the height and maximal width of the barium column were measured at 1 and 10 min.
From 1974 to 1976, homemade pneumodilators were used. Since then, dilation balloons became commercially available, and PD procedures were performed using a Rigiflex balloon (Boston Scientific, Natick, Massachusetts, USA).
Baseline PD was performed on three consecutive days with balloons of either the same or incremental (30, 35 and 40 mm) diameter. We initially used a 40 mm balloon for all three consecutive dilations. Under the assumption of lower perforation risk, we later adapted this protocol to a graduated approach using balloons with incremental diameters of 30, 35 and 40 mm, respectively, inflated like before on successive days. In the case of recurrence, we performed a new series of dilatations on three consecutive days, again with the same protocol as used for initial treatment. After changing our protocol to the graduated approach, all patients with a recurrence were treated with this protocol, irrespective of the earlier balloon diameter protocol used. Under conscious sedation the balloon was positioned fluoroscopically at the gastro-oesophageal junction and inflated to a pressure of 300 mm Hg for 1 min. Until mid-2001 patients were hospitalised for 4–5 days, but later we switched to an outpatient procedure.
We only performed a post-procedural oesophagram using water-soluble contrast on suspicion of a perforation after PD. Dilation of the oesophagus to any extent on a timed barium oesophagram was no exclusion criterion for PD.
Following PD, all patients had a strict schedule of follow-up at 3, 12, 24 months and then every 2 years. Surveillance included gastroscopy, manometry and timed barium oesophagram. After 8 years of follow-up surveillance included gastroscopy; further examination was performed on indication. This schedule was consistently followed for all patients from 1974.
Recurrence of achalasia was defined as relapse of symptoms (in particular dysphagia, regurgitation and weight loss) in combination with an increased LOS pressure on manometry in comparison with the previous LOS pressure, requiring further treatment. We did not use a specific quantified symptom instrument to define symptom recurrence. Primary failure of treatment was defined as the persistence or recurrence of symptoms in the first 3 months after PD.
Evaluation of predictors of disease recurrence
Patient characteristics (age at presentation, gender), the results of timed barium oesophagram, manometry before treatment, PD balloon characteristics (stable vs incremental diameter and complete vs incomplete obliteration of the balloon's waist during PD), as well as the results of repeated manometry 3 months post-treatment were evaluated as predictors of disease recurrence.
Time to recurrence was calculated from first PD. Kaplan–Meier curves were constructed to estimate the 5 and 10-year cumulative incidence of recurrence. Cox proportional hazards regression was used to estimate univariable and multivariable HR. Associations between continuous predictors and recurrence were analysed with restricted cubic spline functions on the log hazard scale.16 These splines allow for a flexible fit of the non-linear effects of predictors with relatively few degrees of freedom (df). The predictive strength of each predictor in the multivariable model was indicated by a χ2 statistic, based on the difference in –2 log likelihood of a model with and without the predictor.17 Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS (version 12.0), and R software (version 2.5.1).
From 1974 to 2006, 433 patients were diagnosed with achalasia based on the above-mentioned criteria. Thirty-seven of them did not undergo PD for various reasons including failure of previous treatment elsewhere, or direct preference for cardiomyotomy. The remaining 396 patients were treated with PD. Sixty (15.2%) of them were excluded from analysis as they had undergone previous endoscopic or surgical treatment elsewhere. The remaining 336 patients were included for analysis, including 161 men and 175 women, with a mean age at initial presentation of 50 years (range 4–92). In 288 of 336 patients a manometric subclassification of achalasia could be made. There were 222 (77%) patients with classic achalasia and 66 (23%) patients with vigorous achalasia. The median follow-up of all patients was 129 months (range 1–378). During follow-up 94 (28%) patients died and 74 (22%) patients were lost to follow-up. Two-hundred and twelve patients (63%) were at baseline treated with the fixed 40 mm balloon protocol, 63 (19%) were treated with the incremental balloon protocol, and the remaining 61 patients were treated with another dilatation protocol, fixed 30 mm balloon, fixed 35 mm balloon or unknown protocol.
Among a total of 985 PD performed in 336 patients, 40 (4.1%) procedures were associated with one or more complications. The complications are summarised in table 1. In 13 (1.3%) of the 985 PD, an oesophageal perforation occurred. Two of these patients required surgery; one patient underwent primary repair of the oesophagus and one patient oesophageal resection. An oesophageal stent was temporarily placed in one patient. The other 10 patients underwent conservative treatment with antibiotics and no oral feeding. There was no mortality and all patients had a good clinical outcome and were discharged 17±7.9 days after the perforation. Perforation occurred in five (2.4%) of the 212 patients who were repeatedly treated with a 40 mm balloon, compared with one (1.6%) of the 63 patients who were treated with incremental size balloons.
Six perforations occurred in patients who were treated with a fixed dilatation protocol with a 35 mm balloon. One perforation occurred in a patient with an unknown dilatation protocol. Perforations occurred in five of 161 (3.1%) men versus eight of 175 (4.6%) women (p <0.001). They were also more common in patients with complete obliteration of the balloon waist (complete vs incomplete 5.1 vs 1.8%, p<0.001). There were no associations between perforation rates and age, LOS pressure on manometry before PD, or duration of achalasia symptoms before diagnosis.
During follow-up, 111 of the 336 patients developed recurrence of achalasia requiring further treatment. These first recurrences occurred at a mean interval of 51 months (range 1–348) after baseline treatment (figure 1). In 12 patients the symptoms persisted or recurred within the first 3 months after PD.
Recurrences were treated with renewed PD in 88 (79%) of the 111 patients, the remainder received other treatment modalities, in particular cardiomyotomy (9%) and botulinum toxin injection (3.6%). The 5-year risk of recurrence was 28%; the 10-year risk of recurrence was 34% (table 2).
Forty-six of the 88 patients who had been treated with repeated PD for disease recurrence developed a second recurrence of achalasia at a mean interval of 70 months (range 13–372) after renewed PD. Second recurrences were treated with renewed PD in 34 (74%) of the 46 patients. Fifteen of those 34 patients developed a third recurrence of achalasia at a mean interval of 109 months (range 22–242) after renewed PD and were then treated with renewed PD in nine (60%) of the 15 patients.
Predictors of outcome: univariate analysis
The risk of recurrence was significantly higher in younger patients, those with classic achalasia, those with incomplete obliteration of the balloon's waist during PD and patients with an LOS pressure greater than 10 mm Hg at 3 months after treatment (table 2). The other factors tested, including gender and balloon diameter used during PD, did not influence the risk of recurrence. Furthermore, the presence or absence of oesophageal dilation on a timed barium oesophagram at presentation as well as LOS pressure before treatment did not significantly differ between patients with or without recurrence of achalasia during follow-up.
Table 2 shows that in 10 patients, a presumptive diagnosis of achalasia was made despite low LOS pressures on manometry. In view of the clinical picture with typical symptoms, a fully compatible barium oesophagram, and a non-relaxing LOS with stasis during endoscopy without signs of obstructing lesions, the presumptive diagnosis of achalasia was made and patients were treated with balloon dilation. The response to this therapy in all 10 patients with improvement of both symptoms and barium oesophagram supported the diagnosis of achalasia and suggest that the low LOS pressures were due to misreading in the manometry. These patients were therefore included in our analysis, separate analysis with the exclusion of these 10 patients did not lead to any major changes in results.
Multivariable analysis showed that age at presentation under 50 years (with increased risk in patients with a younger age), classic achalasia, incomplete obliteration of the balloon's waist during PD and LOS pressure at 3 months after treatment over 12 mm Hg were significant independent factors to predict the development of later recurrence (all p values <0.001). No significant interaction effects were found between these risk factors (all p>0.05), and no simple combinations of characteristics of high-risk patients could be found.
Relative hazard threshold in LOS pressure and age
We examined the relation between LOS pressure measured at 3 months after PD and the risk of recurrence in further detail (figure 2). The higher the LOS pressure post-dilatation, the greater the relative HR for recurrence. We found a threshold value of 12 mm Hg. Above this pressure the risk of recurrence increased more or less linearly. Younger age increased the relative HR for recurrence (figure 3). We found a threshold value of 50 years, below which the risk of recurrence increased linearly.
Patients with achalasia are in many countries primarily treated with PD, as this is considered to be a safe and efficient treatment for this condition. Several studies have reported success rates for PD of between 35% and 85%.4–11 These highly variable results hamper the use of PD as primary treatment for achalasia.
Variation of success rates is possibly due to different periods of follow-up with a gradual decrease in persistent success rates over time. In a study of 72 patients with a mean follow-up of 6.5 years, the risk of recurrence after PD remained as low as 15%.10 Another study showed a persistent treatment success rate of 60% for a patient population followed for 5–9 years post-PD and 40% for patients followed more than 15 years post-PD.7 Our results fit within the above-mentioned range of success. However, given the long follow-up period in our study, we were able to show that the rate of recurrence does indeed increase over time.
Another factor that impairs the direct comparison of different study results is the variable definition of recurrence and success. In some studies, recurrence was defined as symptom recurrence, sometimes based on a symptom score questionnaire such as the Eckardt score,7 whereas other studies divided the data on the effectiveness of treatment into four classes according to Vantrappen and Hellemans.18 This classification is based on symptoms of dysphagia (duration and frequency), regurgitation and weight loss. Others defined success as the absence of the need for further treatment.10 Against this background, we consider our strict protocol of follow-up after PD one of the strengths of our study. In the case of symptom recurrence we performed a gastroscopy, a timed barium oesophagram and a manometry. With this approach, we aimed to confirm an increase in LOS pressures in comparison with previous measurements, thus necessitating repeated treatment.
We deliberately used a clinical definition for persistence and recurrence because this is most applicable and useful in the daily management of achalasia patients. Manometry pressures, timed swallow, or symptoms alone are insufficient tools to diagnose recurrence and repeat PD or proceed to surgery. Our definition of recurrence was deliberately chosen for optimal clinical management and to prevent misdiagnoses.
Another variable factor in the literature concerning PD is the distension protocol used. Until now there has been no strict, uniformly accepted PD protocol for achalasia. Some investigators only perform one dilatation,8 others perform several dilatations with incremental diameter of the balloon, or one dilatation at baseline and every couple of weeks after the first dilatation re-dilatation until clinical remission is achieved.5 7 19 In a retrospective study in a group of 75 achalasia patients, graded dilatation was found to be more effective than a single dilatation.20 In the present study baseline PD was performed on three consecutive days with balloons of either the same diameter, or incremental (30, 35 and 40 mm) diameter. According to the distension protocol, the majority of the patients underwent three consecutive dilatations with a balloon diameter of 40 mm (n=212) or were treated with balloons with increasing diameter, respectively, 30, 35 and eventually 40 mm (n=63). There was no significant difference between both groups with respect to the risk of recurrence.
This study shows that 111 out of 336 patients treated with one series of three PD sessions developed recurrence of achalasia requiring further treatment. These first recurrences occurred at a mean interval of 51 months after baseline treatment. The 5-year risk of recurrence is 28%. In one study with a variable dilation protocol consisting of one to three initial PD sessions, a 5–9 year success of 60% was found after treatment with PD.7 In another study, in which the investigators performed one baseline PD followed by on-demand strategy every 2–3 weeks till clinical remission was achieved, a 5-year persistent success of 67% was reported.5 These studies are in contrast to a study from German investigators,which reported no more than 40% persistent remission 5 years after one baseline PD.8 In comparison with those studies, our 5-year risk of recurrence is relatively low.
After PD, all patients in the present study had a strict schedule of follow-up at 3, 12, 24 months and then every 2 years. Surveillance included gastroscopy, manometry and timed barium oesophagram. After 8 years of follow-up surveillance including gastroscopy, further examination was performed on indication. In another study, patients were not routinely followed up after PD, but were advised to make an appointment when symptoms recurred.7 We believe that symptoms alone are not reliable in assessing treatment success, but an objective assessment of treatment and symptoms is required to achieve a higher treatment success. Patients are used to having a certain level of discomfort due to achalasia. Therefore this group of patients will not present themselves at an early phase of recurrence of disease.
In several studies risk factors for symptom recurrence after PD have been identified. These factors were mainly young age (<40 years), a post-treatment LOS pressure above 10 mm Hg and a short period of symptoms before treatment.5 6 8 12 A severely dilated oesophagus (>80 mm) has been reported to be associated with poor outcome.4 9
We found age to be a predictive factor in treatment outcome. Patients younger than 50 years responded less well to pneumatic dilatation. The risk of recurrence increased linearly in patients with an age below 50 years. High recurrence percentages were found in patients younger than 21 years as the 5-year and 10-year risks of recurrence were 64% and 72%, respectively.
In one study achalasia was categorised into three subtypes; type I as classic achalasia, type II as achalasia with oesophageal compression and type III as achalasia with spastic contractions. That study analysed treatment outcome in 83 patients and showed each subtype to be distinct in their responsiveness to therapy. Type III was a predictor of negative treatment response.21 The current study differentiated achalasia into two subtypes, classic achalasia (type I) and vigorous achalasia (type II). This differentiation could be made in 288 patients. We showed that classic achalasia was associated with a higher risk of recurrence.
In several studies treatment response was associated with low LOS pressures post-dilatation. The most optimal response was found in patients with a post-dilatation LOS pressure lower than 10 mm Hg.8 11 14 The current study confirms that a low LOS pressure post-dilation is associated with a good clinical outcome and shows that a LOS pressure of 12 mm Hg or less at 3 months post-dilatation is associated with a significantly lower risk of recurrence. We therefore recommend the performance of manometry at 3 months post-dilatation to measure LOS pressure as a predictor of treatment outcome.
Incomplete obliteration of the balloon's waist was found to be a significant predictor of clinical outcome as this subgroup showed a significantly higher risk of the development of recurrence. In comparison with patients with complete obliteration, patients without showed a HR of 3.6.
In the present study the presence of dilation of the oesophagus was not associated with an increased risk of recurrence; however, we only scored the parameter dilation/no dilation but did not grade the severity of oesophageal dilation. This does not exclude the possibility that the level of severity of dilation could correlate with the risk of recurrence.
In a study from the USA, investigators showed that patients with a longer duration of symptoms before diagnosis had a more tortuous oesophageal body and tended to have an increased oesophageal diameter observed by radiography.22 It can be hypothesised that early detection of recurrent disease and repeated treatment at an early stage may prevent (further) oesophageal decompensation. Further investigation needs to be performed to confirm this hypothesis.
There are a few shortcomings to our study. First, we did not correlate improved emptying on a barium oesophagram independently with symptom relief, LOS pressures and relapse rates. Second, our pneumatic dilatations stopped at a pressure of 300 mm Hg. We did not increase the balloon pressure until complete obliteration of the balloon waist was achieved in all patients. Therefore our results are not the ultimate standard that can be achieved by PD treatment. Further studies have to show whether differentiation of the approach, for example higher pressure, can improve results without increasing complication rates.
In one of these studies 30.3% of patients initially treated with surgical myotomy had another intervention after 5 years and 37.5% of patients had a subsequent intervention 10 years after initial therapy.26 In our study we obtained similar results with PD, with a 5 and 10-year recurrence rate of 28% and 34%, respectively.
A recently published systemic review showed that laparoscopic myotomy combined with an antireflux procedure provided better symptom relief (90%) than all endoscopic and other surgical approaches, with a low complication rate (6.3%).27
Recently, a large European prospective randomised study compared laparoscopic Heller myotomy versus PD as baseline treatment in 200 achalasia patients.28 One hundred and six patients were treated with laparoscopic Heller myotomy with Dor fundoplication and 94 patients were treated with pneumatic dilation. After 2 years of follow-up both treatments had a comparable success rate of 92% versus 87%. Further follow-up is required to evaluate long-term outcome. The long-term outcome of this study should further determine which therapy should be reserved for different subgroups of achalasia patients as baseline therapy.
In summary, we conclude that PD is an effective treatment for achalasia, but that recurrence rates after PD increase over time. Young age at presentation, classic achalasia, incomplete obliteration of the balloon's waist during PD, and high LOS pressure at 3 months after PD are independent predicting factors of the need for repeated PD during follow-up. These factors should be taken into account in the follow-up strategy of achalasia patients, leading to a stricter follow-up protocol in patients with the above-mentioned predicting factors. Such a protocol should aim for the timely detection of recurrence (defined as symptom recurrence in combination with objective parameters such as a significant increase in LOS pressure) with renewed, tailored treatment. Our results show that most patients are then eligible for renewed PD. However, selected cases such as those 21 years of age or younger may in the case of recurrence be referred for surgery earlier.
Competing interests None.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.