Objective Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is a prevalent and aggressive cancer usually arising on a background of chronic liver injury involving inflammatory and hepatic regenerative processes. The triggering receptor expressed on myeloid cells 2 (TREM-2) is predominantly expressed in hepatic non-parenchymal cells and inhibits Toll-like receptor signalling, protecting the liver from various hepatotoxic injuries, yet its role in liver cancer is poorly defined. Here, we investigated the impact of TREM-2 on liver regeneration and hepatocarcinogenesis.
Design TREM-2 expression was analysed in liver tissues of two independent cohorts of patients with HCC and compared with control liver samples. Experimental HCC and liver regeneration models in wild type and Trem-2-/- mice, and in vitro studies with hepatic stellate cells (HSCs) and HCC spheroids were conducted.
Results TREM-2 expression was upregulated in human HCC tissue, in mouse models of liver regeneration and HCC. Trem-2-/- mice developed more liver tumours irrespective of size after diethylnitrosamine (DEN) administration, displayed exacerbated liver damage, inflammation, oxidative stress and hepatocyte proliferation. Administering an antioxidant diet blocked DEN-induced hepatocarcinogenesis in both genotypes. Similarly, Trem-2-/- animals developed more and larger tumours in fibrosis-associated HCC models. Trem-2-/- livers showed increased hepatocyte proliferation and inflammation after partial hepatectomy. Conditioned media from human HSCs overexpressing TREM-2 inhibited human HCC spheroid growth in vitro through attenuated Wnt ligand secretion.
Conclusion TREM-2 plays a protective role in hepatocarcinogenesis via different pleiotropic effects, suggesting that TREM-2 agonism should be investigated as it might beneficially impact HCC pathogenesis in a multifactorial manner.
- hepatocellular carcinoma
- immune-mediated liver damage
- liver immunology
- liver regeneration
- molecular carcinogenesis
Data availability statement
Data are available upon reasonable request. Email address: email@example.com.
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
- hepatocellular carcinoma
- immune-mediated liver damage
- liver immunology
- liver regeneration
- molecular carcinogenesis
Significance of this study
What is already known on this subject?
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is a prevalent cancer and its pathogenesis is a multistep process involving the progressive accumulation of molecular alterations. HCC usually arises on a background of chronic liver injury involving inflammatory and hepatic regenerative processes.
Increasing evidence suggests the gut–liver axis and innate immunity play a critical role in the development and progression of several liver diseases, including HCC. Fine-tuning of Toll-like receptor (TLR)-driven inflammation during liver cancer is key.
The triggering receptor expressed on myeloid cells 2 (TREM-2) negatively regulates TLR-mediated inflammatory responses.
TREM-2 is expressed on non-parenchymal liver cells and is upregulated during diverse forms of liver injury in humans and mice. TREM-2 promotes the resolution of inflammation during diverse types of hepatic injury, ultimately preventing parenchymal cell death.
Significance of this study
What are the new findings?
TREM-2 expression is upregulated in human HCC tissue, in mouse models of liver regeneration and HCC.
In human HCC tumours, TREM-2 is expressed in infiltrating monocyte derived macrophages.
Trem-2-/- mice developed increased number of liver tumours after diethylnitrosamine (DEN) administration, displayed exacerbated liver damage, inflammation, oxidative stress and hepatocyte proliferation.
Liver cancer in Trem-2-/- mice is associated with elevated reactive oxygen species levels and the administration of an antioxidant diet blocked DEN-induced DNA damage and hepatocarcinogenesis in these animals.
In fibrosis-associated HCC models, Trem-2-/- mice also exhibited elevated tumour burden and less fibrosis.
Trem-2-/- livers exhibited increased hepatocyte proliferation and inflammation after partial hepatectomy (PHx). The suppressive effects of this receptor on hepatocyte proliferation were linked to its effects on early inflammatory events post-PHx.
In line with TREM-2 effects on inflammation and proliferation, conditioned media from human hepatic stellate cells overexpressing TREM-2 inhibited human HCC spheroid growth in vitro.
How might it impact on clinical practice in the foreseeable future?
While strategies aiming to activate TREM-2 in the context of HCC are warranted, as TREM-2 agonism might beneficially impact tumour burden in a pleiotropic manner, they will require a detailed evaluation for potential profibrotic side-effects.
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is the sixth most common cancer and the third leading cause of cancer-related mortality worldwide. HCC usually arises on the background of chronic liver injury and inflammation, mainly triggered by infectious agents (eg, hepatitis B and C virus), alcohol abuse and/or excessive hepatocellular fat accumulation.1 During the past few years, it has become evident that innate immunity plays a critical role in the development and progression of several liver diseases, including HCC.2
The triggering receptor expressed on myeloid cells 2 (TREM-2) is an anti-inflammatory receptor that negatively regulates toll-like receptor (TLR)-mediated inflammatory responses, whereas the proinflammatory receptor TREM-1 augments TLR-induced inflammation.3 4 Both receptors signal through the immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif of the adaptor protein DAP-12.5 The ligand(s) for TREM-2 are unknown although numerous are proposed, ranging from various anionic molecules; phospholipids, proteoglycans to apolipoproteins and heat shock proteins.6–9 TREM-2 has been mainly studied in the brain, where its deficiency in microglia is associated with several neurodegenerative disorders, including Alzheimer’s disease.10–12 The role of TREM-2 in cancer is poorly understood, although several studies suggest that high TREM-2 expression correlates with worsened outcome during various cancers including gastric, glioma and renal cell carcinoma.13–15 On the other hand, in the liver, we recently described that TREM-2 is predominantly expressed in non-parenchymal cells (ie, Kupffer cells (KCs) and hepatic stellate cells (HSCs)), where it serves to attenuate TLR4-mediated cytokine production.16 Notably, herein we could show that mice deficient for Trem-2 displayed increased liver damage and inflammation post-acetaminophen and acute or chronic carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) administration. Given the crucial role of innate immunity in HCC, we hypothesised that TREM-2 could play a protective role in its development and progression.
Materials and methods
TREM-2 expression was determined in 366 HCC and 49 non-tumour tissues surrounding HCC from the RNAseq data of the cancer genome atlas (TCGA) (‘TCGA cohort’) in Reads per Kilobase Million. Level 3 RNA-seq data generated by The Cancer Genome Atlas Liver Hepatocellular Carcinoma (TCGA-LIHC) consortium were downloaded from the National Cancer Institute Genomic Data Commons (https://gdc.cancer.gov/).17 Moreover, 35 HCC human biopsies of different etiologies and 21 control liver tissues (from non-neoplastic liver tissue of patients with colorectal hepatic metastasis) were obtained from the Biobank of Donostia University Hospital (‘San Sebastian cohort’) for the analysis of TREM-2 expression and several pro-fibrotic and pro-inflammatory genes by quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR). Patient information is detailed in online supplementary table 1. Samples and clinicopathological information were obtained from the Basque Biobank. Single-cell transcriptome profiling of human HCC tumour biospecimens from nine HCC tumours was downloaded from Gene Expression Ominbus (GSE125449). Patient specific characteristics of this data set are previously described and all patients provided informed consent.18 Briefly, HCC tumour samples of various aetiologies were obtained by resection or needle biopsy from five males (ages 61–77) and four females (ages 41–64), with several patients receiving immunotherapy.18
Wild type (WT) C57BL/6 and Trem-2 -/- mice backcrossed onto a>98% C57BL/6 background were generated as previously described.3 Mice were bred and housed at the animal facility of the Biodonostia Health Research Institute in the same room under specific pathogen free conditions with microisolator tops. All experiments were performed under approval of the Animal Experimentation Ethics Committee of the Institution.
HCC was induced in WT and Trem-2 -/- male mice by the administration of a single intraperitoneal injection of the hepatocarcinogen diethylnitrosamine (DEN; Sigma-Aldrich) (30 mg/kg of DEN dissolved in 0.9% saline) at 15 days of age. Mice were humanely killed at 30 or 40 weeks post-injection. To evaluate the role of reactive oxygen species (ROS), 15 weeks after DEN administration, both genotypes were fed a diet supplemented with 0.7% w/w of the antioxidant butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA; Sigma-Aldrich) for another 15 weeks prior to sacrifice. To evaluate effects of acute DEN treatment on the liver, 8 week-old male WT and Trem-2 -/- mice were injected with 100 mg/kg DEN and sacrificed 6, 24 and 72 hours post-injection. Regenerative responses were evaluated in 8 week-old male WT and Trem-2-/- mice using partial hepatectomy (PHx ~70%), as previously described.19 To stain proliferating hepatocytes, mice were intraperitoneally injected with 150 mg/kg of 5′-bromo-2′-deoxyuridine (BRDU; Sigma-Aldrich) 2 hours before humane killing. Fibrosis-associated HCC was induced in WT and Trem-2-/- male mice by combining chronic DEN administration (30 mg/kg, intraperitoneal, 15 days post-partum) with 10 weekly injections (one injection per week) of CCl4 at 2 µL/g body weight (CCl4/olive oil 1:3 (vol:vol)), starting at 4 weeks of age (2 weeks after DEN injection). Mice were humanely killed 30 weeks after DEN injection. As a second approach for fibrosis-associated HCC, 8 week-old WT and Trem-2-/- male mice were administered 0.03% (w/v) thioacetamide (TAA) (Sigma-Aldrich) in drinking water for 40 weeks. Tumour volume in animals was calculated using the formula Tv = (W(2) × L)/2.20
Gain-of-function experiments were performed overexpressing TREM-2 in 8-week-old WT C57BL/6 mice by intravenous tail vein injection with control (AAV8-CMV-eGFP; VECTOR Biosystems) or Trem-2 overexpressing adeno-associated viruses (AAV8-CMV-TREM-2-IRES-eGFP; VECTOR Biosystems) (1×1011 pfu) dissolved in 0.9% saline. Next, 72 hours after AAV injection, mice were injected with DEN (100 mg/kg) and sacrificed 72 hours post-DEN.
Statistical analysis was performed with GraphPad Prism V.6.00 software (GraphPad Software, San Diego, CA). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM). For comparisons between two groups, parametric Student’s t-test or non-parametric Mann-Whitney test were used. When more than two groups were compared, one-way analysis of variance with Tukey’s posthoc test or Kruskal-Wallis test followed by Dunn’s multiple comparison test were used. For correlation analysis, non-parametric Spearman’s correlation test was used. Statistically significant differences are represented in figures as *, **, ***, **** for p values <0.05, <0.01, < 0.001 and <0.0001, respectively.
Additional methods are described in the online supplementary materials.
TREM-2 is upregulated in human HCC, is prominently expressed in tumour infiltrating macrophages, correlating with markers of inflammation and fibrosis
To explore a potential role for TREM-2 in HCC, we first analysed TREM-2 expression in human HCC tumours and control liver tissue (ie, non-tumour surrounding and healthy liver tissues) using two different approaches (ie, RNA-seq and qPCR) and two different patient cohorts (ie, TCGA and San Sebastian, respectively). Consistent with observations in other cancers including gastric, renal and brain cancers, where elevated TREM-2 was observed in tumour versus control tissues,13–15 TREM-2 expression was upregulated in HCC samples compared with non-tumour surrounding liver tissues of the ‘TCGA cohort’ (figure 1A). Similarly, opposed to normal liver tissues, TREM-2 levels were increased in HCC tumour tissues of the ‘San Sebastian cohort’ (figure 1A). Tumour stage stratification of the TCGA cohort revealed that TREM-2 expression was increased in advanced (T4 stage) versus early (T1 stage) HCC tumours (online supplementary figure 1). Evaluating TREM-2 expression using immunohistochemistry in human healthy liver and HCC tumours of variable aetiology and surrounding cirrhotic liver tissue (online supplementary table 2) verified that TREM-2 expression was more extensive in diseased compared with control liver (figure 1B). Importantly, while TREM-2 was not expressed in transformed hepatocytes, TREM-2 immunostaining was observed in inflammatory periportal areas in the surrounding cirrhotic tissue and adjacent tissue to the fibrotic septa of patients with HCC. Expression was also prominent within infiltrating or resident cells within HCC tumours of various aetiologies and these cells morphologically resembled macrophages (figure 1B and online supplementary figure 2A). We noted that although compared with control liver, TREM-2 immunostaining was extensive in both the surrounding cirrhotic and tumour tissue of HCC patients in the ‘San Sebastian cohort’, there was no striking differences in immunostaining intensity between the tumour and its surroundings (figure 1B and online supplementary figure 2A). TREM-2 mRNA levels (qPCR) of patient matched surrounding versus tumour tissue in the ‘San Sebastian cohort’ demonstrated patient-specific variability with some patients exhibiting downregulation of TREM-2 in tumour versus surrounding cirrhotic tissue and others upregulation (online supplementary figure 2B). As liver inflammation and fibrosis are important for HCC progression,1 we next correlated TREM-2 expression with several pro-fibrotic (COL1A1 and ACTA2) and pro-inflammatory (IL1B, IL6, IL8 and TNF) genes in the HCC tumour samples from the ‘San Sebastian cohort’. While no correlation was observed for ACTA2, TREM-2 expression positively correlated with COL1A1, IL1B, IL6, IL8 and TNF levels (online supplementary figure 3). Similar results were observed in HCC samples from the TCGA cohort, although TREM-2 expression here also significantly correlated with ACTA2 (online supplementary table 3). Thus, compared with control human liver, TREM-2 expression is increased in HCC tumours and correlates with inflammatory and fibrotic genes.
We next examined which cell types express TREM-2 in HCC human liver tumours. We utilised publicly available single-cell RNA sequencing data from nine HCC livers, encompassing both malignant and non-malignant cell types18 and post-data processing, visualised the clustered data using t-distributed Stochastic Neighbour Embedding (t-SNE) through the Seurat R package. In line with previously published observations encompassing this data set,18 we identified six clusters annotated to T cells, B cells, cancer-associated fibroblasts, tumour-associated macrophages, tumour-associated endothelial cells and hepatic progenitor like (HPC-like) cells using known cell lineage-specific marker genes (figure 1C, online supplementary figure 4). HCC malignant cells were cell annotated based on RNA-seq derived large-scale chromosomal copy-number variations prediction from the previously published work encompassing this data set.18 These cell types clustered together with HPC-like cells (figure 1C). Notably, this cluster was rich in expression of markers typical of transformed hepatocytes possessing stem/progenitor properties including alpha-fetoprotein (AFP), albumin (ALB), keratin 19 (KRT19), CD24 and SOX9 (online supplementary figure 5).21–24 Importantly, and in accordance with our immunohistochemistry data (figure 1B), TREM-2 expression was most prominent in macrophages and markedly increased compared with malignant cells/transformed hepatocytes (figure 1D,E). Refined-clustering of the macrophage cluster in human HCC, demonstrated distinct clusters with prominent TREM-2 expression in clusters 1 and 2 that were characterised by expression of the resident KC marker CD68 and the monocyte marker CD14 (figure 1F).25–27 Furthermore, in line with recent work demonstrating the presence of monocyte derived TREM-2+CD9+ scar-associated macrophages (SAMacs) in human liver cirrhosis,28 the macrophage cluster was characterised by CD9 presence (figure 1G). In silico-based cellular deconvolution of the RNA-seq TCGA data subsequently correlating TREM-2 expression with innate and adaptive immune cell gene signatures present in HCC further suggested that in human HCC, TREM-2 was mainly expressed by macrophages/monocytes as out of the deconvoluted cell types, TREM-2 positively correlated with macrophages and monocytes but not with CD4+ or CD8+ T cells nor with neutrophils or endothelial cells (online supplementary table 4). We identified 42 differentially expressed genes between TREM-2 expressing (clusters 1 and 2; figure 1F), and non-expressing (clusters 0, 3, 4 and 5, figure 1F) tumour infiltrating macrophages (online supplementary figure 6). Gene set enrichment analysis demonstrated enrichment in TLR signalling and lysosome-associated pathways (figure 1H), implying overlapping functions between TREM-2 expressing tumour infiltrating macrophages and resident TREM-2 expressing KCs, in the negative regulation of TLR-induced inflammation.16 Enrichments of lysosome-associated pathways are consistent with recent published observations examining TREM-2 function in KCs,29 further suggesting functional similarities between TREM-2 expressing resident KCs and tumour infiltrating macrophages.
Together, these observations indicated a particular importance for TREM-2 expression in tumour infiltrating monocyte-derived macrophages in HCC, suggesting their associated effects with inflammation and fibrosis might be involved in HCC development and/or progression.
TREM-2 attenuates oxidative stress, inflammation and hepatocyte damage during the early phases of liver tumourigenesis
To determine the role of TREM-2 in the early phases of HCC, we performed the well-established model of acute DEN administration, which provides significant insight into the inflammatory mechanisms at play during HCC.30 31 We thus acutely injected 8 week-old Trem-2-/- or WT control mice with 100 mg/kg DEN and humanely sacrificed both genotypes at different time points (figure 2A). H&E staining revealed more extensive liver damage in Trem-2-/- versus WT animals, associated with augmented hepatic phospho-histone H2AX (γH2AX) levels, a surrogate marker for DNA damage (figure 2B, C). Consistently, while there were no baseline differences in circulating alanine aminotransferase (ALT) levels between genotypes, significantly elevated ALT was found in Trem-2-/- mice post-DEN versus controls (figure 2D). Notably, increased levels of hepatic ROS were observed in Trem-2-/- compared with WT mice post-DEN (figure 2E). This was associated with increased inflammatory (C–X–C motif chemokine ligand 1 (Cxcl1), chemokine (C–C motif) ligand two or monocyte chemoattractant protein 1 (Mcp1), tumour necrosis factor (Tnf)), mitogenic (hepatocyte growth factort (Hgf)) and oxidative stress-related gene expression ((Hmox1) heme oxygenase 1) in Trem-2-/- compared with WT animals (figure 2F). However, we did not observe differences in hepatic immune cell recruitment between genotypes (online supplementary figure 7). These data suggested an importance for TREM-2 in suppressing inflammation, ROS production and consequent liver damage during the initiation of DEN-induced carcinogenesis. To corroborate these findings, we next performed gain-of-function experiments. We intravenously injected WT C57BL/6 animals with either a control adenovirus or an adenovirus encoding TREM-2 under the transcriptional control of the cytomegalovirus promoter. Seventy-two hours post-virus infection, we acutely injected mice with DEN and evaluated both groups of animals 72 hours post-DEN (figure 3A). Ratifying transduction efficiency, TREM-2 was robustly expressed in animals injected with TREM-2 overexpressing versus control virus (figure 3B). While there was a slight tendency for ALT levels to be decreased in TREM-2 overexpressing animals opposed to controls, significantly attenuated serum aspartate aminotransferase and alkaline phosphatase levels verified TREM-2 attenuated DEN-mediated liver damage (figure 3C). Importantly, the hepatoprotective effects of TREM-2 overexpression were linked to less ROS and MCP-1 production (figure 3D,E). Thus, complimentary approaches, encompassing animals both genetically lacking and overexpressing TREM-2, demonstrate that it attenuates hepatic damage, inflammation and oxidative stress in the early phases of HCC.
Trem-2 plays a protective role in HCC
To formally investigate the role of TREM-2 in hepatocarcinogenesis, we next performed a chronic DEN model, where we injected the hepatocarcinogen DEN or saline control to both genotypes and sacrificed them 30 and 40 weeks post-DEN administration (figure 4A). In parallel, as ROS are important for HCC development32 and we had observed elevated hepatic ROS in Trem-2 deficient animals (figure 2E), and decreased ROS in those experimentally overexpressing TREM-2 (figure 3D), we chronically fed both mouse genotypes a diet supplemented with the antioxidant BHA (figure 4B). Opposed to saline controls, hepatic Trem-2 levels were increased in the non-tumour tissue of DEN-administered mice (figure 4C). Regarding Trem-2 expression in tumour tissue versus matched non-tumour tissue, Trem-2 was markedly increased in tumour samples, particularly 40 weeks post-DEN (figure 4D). Remarkably, macroscopic liver analysis demonstrated that DEN-administered Trem-2-/- mice developed more tumours than controls at both time points (figure 4E). Analysis of tumour size revealed that Trem-2 deficient animals exhibited increased numbers of small (≤2 mm) and big (≥6 mm) tumours, and more small and medium size (2–6 mm) tumours 30 and 40 weeks post-DEN, respectively (online supplementary figure 8). Notably, BHA administration reversed the elevated tumourigenesis of Trem-2-/- mice, supporting an involvement of ROS in the protective effects mediated by TREM-2 (figure 4F). Of note, the antioxidant regimen also extensively lowered tumour burden of WT mice, which is consistent with DEN-mediated tumourigenesis being blocked by antioxidants.30 33
We next set out to confirm these macroscopic observations and elaborate on the potential mechanisms behind them. H&E staining confirmed increased hepatic tumours in Trem-2-/- animals (figure 5A). To evaluate hepatocyte proliferation in pre-neoplastic surrounding liver tissue, we next measured proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) expression using IHC. Post-DEN, Trem-2-/- mice exhibited increased numbers of PCNA-positive hepatocytes in the surrounding tissue versus controls, irrespective of time point (figure 5B). Similarly, IHC analysis of γH2AX revealed an increased number of γH2AX-positive hepatocytes in Trem-2-/- livers compared with WT at both time points (figure 5C). Consistent with findings during acute DEN, evaluating hepatic immune cell recruitment revealed minor differences between genotypes post-DEN (online supplementary figure 9). Furthermore, caspase-3/7 activation and protein levels of the kinase receptor-interacting protein kinase 3 as well as phosphorylation of its downstream substrate mixed lineage kinase domain-like34 were similar between genotypes 30 and 40 weeks post-DEN (online supplementary figure 10).
In line with ROS playing critical roles in DNA damage and cellular proliferation during HCC,35 the BHA regimen (figure 4B) attenuated PCNA and γH2AX levels in both mouse genotypes and reversed the effects of Trem-2 abrogation (figure 5B and C). Likely reflective of better HCC outcome in general in the context of antioxidants, levels of certain pro-inflammatory cytokines including Tnf and Rantes were attenuated in both genotypes of BHA-treated animals (online supplementary figure 11A). Furthermore, we did not detect any differences in pro-inflammatory cytokines 30 or 40 weeks post-DEN between genotypes (online supplementary figure 11A). In line with this, no differences in c-jun n-terminal kinase activation were observed between genotypes (online supplementary figure 11B). These data suggested a particular importance for TREM-2 in restraining inflammation during the priming phase of DEN-induced HCC (figure 2F). Consistent with the importance of ROS in TREM-2’s protective effects in HCC, 40 weeks post-DEN, we observed a strong tendency (p=0.0582) towards higher hepatic inducible nitric oxide synthase (Inos) levels in Trem-2-/- animals (online supplementary figure 12A). As Inos is a marker for classically activated M1 macrophages,36 we next examined whether in chronic DEN, there were any differences in genes associated with alternatively activated M2 macrophages, cells that play a modulatory role in hepatic fibrosis.36 37 Among the tested markers (Arg1, FIZZ-1 and CD206), we could not observe any changes nor were there differences in the pro-fibrogenic mediator Tgf-β (online supplementary figure 12B). Despite no influences of TREM-2 on Tgf-β in DEN-instigated HCC, based on our published observations demonstrating that TREM-2 is markedly upregulated in activated HSCs16 and that TREM-2 correlates with collagen levels in human HCC (online supplementary figure 3), we next correlated hepatic Trem-2 levels with pro-fibrotic markers that are prominent during HSC activation in non-tumour liver tissue of WT mice after DEN administration (30 and 40 weeks). By doing so, we could observe that Trem-2 levels correlated with Col1a1 and Acta2 levels (figure 5D), suggesting TREM-2 expression within activated HSCs might regulate HCC development and/or progression.
Together, these data indicate that alterations in M1/M2 macrophage polarisation, necroptosis or apoptosis between genotypes do not account for the worsened outcome of TREM-2 deficient mice in HCC. Notably, they further suggest that elevated DNA damage and proliferation mediated through oxidative stress is key to the worsened outcome of Trem-2-deficient animals. This hypothesis is supported by proteomic analysis of liver tumour tissue post-DEN. Herein, several proteins were significantly and differentially expressed between genotypes (online supplementary figure 13), and gene ontology analysis revealed enrichment of biological processes including oxidoreductase activity and lipid metabolism (online supplementary table 5).
TREM-2 exerts tumourigenic protective effects in fibrosis-associated HCC
To strengthen the protective effects of TREM-2 in HCC and to examine its potential impact on fibrosis-associated hepatocarcinogenesis, we next performed two different HCC models. CCl4 induces hepatic fibrosis and is frequently combined with DEN administration to study fibrosis-associated HCC.38 We thus combined chronic DEN with 10 weekly CCl4 injections starting at week 4 and harvested both genotypes at week 30 (figure 6A). DEN/CCl4 administration led to increased numbers of small (≤2 mm) tumours in Trem-2-/- animals versus controls at 30 weeks (figure 6B), consistent with the effects of DEN alone at this time point (online supplementary figure 8). Evaluating fibrosis using Sirius red staining, surprisingly demonstrated that despite the enhanced tumourigenesis of Trem-2-/- mice versus controls, these animals displayed less fibrosis (figure 6C). Furthermore, increased PCNA transcription in DEN/CCl4-treated Trem-2 -/- animals suggested increased hepatocyte proliferation (figure 6D). As a second model of fibrosis-associated HCC, TAA was administered to both genotypes in drinking water,38 starting at week 8 of age, and animals harvested 40 weeks post-TAA administration (figure 6E). Trem-2-deficient animals exhibited larger tumours post-TAA versus controls (figure 6F) and akin to the DEN/CCl4 model, this was associated with attenuated fibrosis and increased PCNA levels (figure 6G,H). Together, these data encompassing diverse murine models unequivocally demonstrate that TREM-2 restrains tumour development and proliferation in HCC. They further suggest that although TREM-2 promotes fibrosis in HCC, these effects are disassociated from HCC development, supporting recent work indicating that the molecular players in fibrosis and HCC can be uncoupled.39 40
Increased hepatocyte proliferation in Trem-2-/- mice following PHx
Given the importance of liver regenerative mechanisms in HCC,41 and the elevated hepatocyte proliferation of Trem-2-deficient animals versus controls post-DEN as well as in the fibrosis-associated HCC models (figures 5 and 6), we next investigated how TREM-2 impacts hepatocyte proliferation using PHx. We thus subjected both genotypes to ~70% PHx, subsequently sacrificing them at different time points. Trem-2 levels increased robustly post-PHx, with a peak of expression 48 hours post-surgery relative to sham-operated mice, suggestive of a potential role in liver regeneration (figure 7A). Strikingly, two independent methods of evaluating hepatocyte proliferation (ie, PCNA immunostaining and BRDU incorporation) revealed increased hepatocyte proliferation in Trem-2-/- versus WT control animals after PHx (figure 7B,C). PCNA immunoblotting confirmed this result (figure 7D). As the priming phase of liver regeneration preceding hepatocyte proliferation is associated with inflammatory cytokine upregulation,42 we next hypothesised that perhaps during PHx TREM-2’s suppressive effects on hepatocyte proliferation was linked to effects of this receptor on early inflammatory events after PHx. Indeed, elevated hepatocyte proliferation of Trem-2-deficient animals was associated with an early augmentation of inflammation as revealed by increased levels of pro-inflammatory genes (ie, Tnf, Il6). Notably, hepatic levels of Hgf were also increased early in Trem-2-/- opposed to WT animals after PHx (figure 7E). As IL-6 activates STAT3 in PHx,43 levels of phosphorylated STAT3 were analysed by immunoblotting in both genotypes 6 hours post-PHx. Increased Il6 levels 6 hours post-PHx in Trem-2 deficient animals did not result in more hepatic STAT3 activation (online supplementary figure 14A). Lipid accumulation during liver regeneration induces transient steatosis and lipids might be used as a source of energy to ensure proper hepatic regeneration and proliferation.44 45 Considering an enrichment in lipid metabolism-related processes was observed post-DEN in Trem-2-/- compared with WT animals (online supplementary table 5), we next evaluated hepatic triglyceride content. Compared with control animals, hepatic triglycerides accumulated 6 hours post-PHx, but there were no genotype specific differences (online supplementary figure 14B). Similarly, there were no differences in serum triglycerides post-DEN (online supplementary figure 14C). Thus, TREM-2 restrains hepatocyte proliferation, an effect likely independent of triglyceride production but linked to hepatic inflammation and growth factor production.
Overexpression of TREM-2 in HSC modulates Wnt ligand secretion and reduces HCC tumourigenicity
Although our single-cell RNA sequencing analysis of human HCC tumour samples demonstrated that TREM-2 is primarily expressed in tumour infiltrated macrophages (figure 1), we previously demonstrated that TREM-2 is robustly expressed in activated human and murine HSCs during liver injury where it serves to modulate TLR-mediated inflammation.16 It is well established that activated HSCs infiltrate the tumour stroma, secrete extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins and favour HCC tumourigenicity through changes in their secretory phenotype.46–48 Given this, together with our aforementioned published work and that Trem-2 levels in non-tumour liver tissue of WT mice post-DEN correlated with Col1a1 and Acta2 levels (figure 5D), we next explored whether HSC expressed TREM-2 might impact HCC growth. To evaluate this and translate these findings to the human situation, we next developed a 3D spheroid model. Such models have proved to be invaluable for studying the interactions between cancer cells and their surrounding environment.49 50 We thus overexpressed TREM-2 in human HSCs (ie, LX-2 cells) in vitro and after confirming successful overexpression (figure 8A), carried out culture hanging droplet liver cancer spheroid growth assays with two different HCC cancer cell lines (Hep3B and PLC/PRF5) with the supernatant of these cells versus HSCs that had received a control plasmid. Strikingly, supernatant of TREM-2 overexpressing LX-2 cells markedly reduced 3D Hep3B HCC spheroid growth compared with control conditions, suggesting TREM-2 modulated the HSC secretome in a manner that negatively influences HCC proliferation (figure 8B). Similar effects were observed with PLC/PRF5 HCC cells, demonstrating they are not cell-type specific (online supplementary figure 15). Considering the anti-inflammatory effects of Trem-2 during both PHx (figure 7E) and acute DEN (figure 2F), we next examined whether the aforementioned decreases in HCC spheroid growth instigated by TREM-2 overexpressing HSC supernatant were associated with attenuated basal HSC cytokine expression and secretion. Indeed, both TNF and MCP-1 mRNA and protein levels in HSCs were attenuated on experimental TREM-2 overexpression (figure 8C, online supplementary figure 16).
Given the major role of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway in HCC51 52 and that TREM-2 is described to modulate this pathway in other cellular systems including the bone and brain,53 54 we next evaluated potential effects of TREM-2 on Wnt signalling and HCC growth. TREM-2 overexpression in HSCs attenuated the expression of the canonical Wnt ligands, WNT3, WNT7A and WNT8A suggesting TREM-2 in HSCs might attenuate HCC growth through paracrine Wnt-dependent signalling (figure 8C). To expand on this idea, we next incubated HCC spheroids with TREM-2 overexpressing or control HSC (LX-2) supernatant in the presence or absence of the β-catenin inhibitor IWR-1. Concordant with expression of Wnt ligands in HSCs (figure 8C, white bars), HCC spheroid growth was dependent on Wnt signalling as it was substantially reduced by IWR-1 under control conditions (figure 8D, red bars). Furthermore, the HCC growth-attenuating effect of supernatant from TREM-2 overexpressing HSCs was abolished in IWR-1-treated cells (figure 8D), implicating the effects of TREM-2 on Wnt/β-catenin signalling in HCC growth. Further evidence was obtained from experiments where we blocked Wnt ligand secretion (with the IWP-2 inhibitor) in both sets of HSCs and observed that blocking Wnt ligand secretion abolished the differences associated with TREM-2 overexpression (figure 8E). To rule out potential autocrine effects of IWP-2 treatment on the HCC spheroid (ie, effects of Wnt ligand secretion within the HCC cells), we performed control conditions where in parallel we directly added IWP-2 to HCC spheroids in the presence of supernatant from both sets of HSCs. Strikingly, TREM-2 overexpressing LX-2 supernatant still attenuated HCC growth in these conditions (figure 8E). Together, these data assign a potential function for TREM-2 in influencing the HSC secretome and reducing HCC tumourigenicity via paracrine mechanisms that rely on Wnt signalling.
The role of the immune receptor TREM-2 in human neurodegenerative disorders is currently under intense investigation.10–12 However, its impact on cancer,13–15 55 and particularly HCC, is almost unknown. HCC is a common deadly cancer, often arising during chronic liver injury. Therefore, there is an urgent need to identify hepatic anti-inflammatory players and mechanisms regulating hepatocarcinogenesis, as they might represent potential nodes for therapy. We recently reported that TREM-2 is preferentially expressed in non-parenchymal liver cells (ie, KCs and HSCs) acting as a natural inflammation brake during diverse hepatotoxic injuries.16 Based on these observations, we hypothesised a protective role for TREM-2 in HCC. Here, we found upregulated TREM-2 expression in HCC tissues versus control liver tissues. Although high TREM-2 expression in surrounding cirrhotic and HCC tumour tissue versus control liver was evident, consistent with published observations indicating TREM-2 is downregulated in patient matched HCC tumour versus surrounding tissue,56 we observed patient-specific heterogeneity, with some patients exhibiting TREM-2 downregulation and others upregulation. Regardless of this heterogeneity, which might be explained by tumour cell biodiversity,18 here we find that TREM-2 expression in human HCC tumours correlated with markers of inflammation and fibrosis.
HCC usually originates in cirrhosis-associated hepatocellular nodules under regeneration. Here, environmental cues are key and if newly generated hepatocytes are exposed to abnormal chronic inflammation, normal liver regenerative responses shift towards malignancy linked to excessive hepatic proliferation, genomic instability and tumourigenesis.57 The early phase of liver regeneration post-PHx is characterised by elevated TNF and IL-6 expression, which are mainly produced by KCs and HSCs.58 Notably, the expression of these cytokines, as well as Hgf, are increased in Trem-2-/- animals versus WT controls after PHx and this is accompanied with increased hepatocyte proliferation. Although TREM-2 negatively regulates TLR4-mediated inflammation in KCs and HSCs, our previous observations demonstrating equivalent inflammation in TNF or IL-1 challenged Trem-2-/- KCs and HSCs versus controls demonstrate that TREM-2 does not directly influence non-parenchymal hepatic cell cytokine signalling.16 Interestingly, Tlr4 -/- mice display similar regenerative responses post-PHx to WT controls, suggesting lipopolysaccharide signalling is not required for hepatic regenerative responses.59 60 Similarly opposed to controls, identical hepatic regeneration reportedly occurs in TLR2-deficient and TLR9-deficient animals, indicating that responses to lipotechoic acid or bacterial DNA, ligands of the aforementioned TLRs whose signalling is modulated by TREM-2, is dispensable for liver regeneration.3 59–61 Thus TREM-2’s suppressive effects on hepatocyte proliferation might occur following engagement of multiple TLR ligands. Alternatively, TREM-2 could impact hepatic regenerative responses TLR independently, possibly through its postulated ligands that include phospholipids, proteoglycans, apolipoproteins and heat shock protein 60.6–9 Interestingly, several of these are associated with regenerative responses either in the liver or in other systems and organisms.45 62 63 Regardless of the exact upstream mechanism, our PHx data support the notion that TREM-2’s effects on inflammation and growth factor production are intertwined with hepatic regenerative responses.
The tumour microenvironment plays a fundamental role in HCC development and progression, and comprises inflammatory cytokines, growth factors, proteolytic enzymes, non-parenchymal hepatic cells, immune cells and ECM proteins.48 While during murine HCC we observed no impact of TREM-2 on immune cell recruitment, hepatic Trem-2 levels correlated with HSC activation in surrounding non-tumour liver tissue, consistent with the idea that in mice TREM-2-expressing activated HSCs infiltrate the tumour microenvironment. However, in fibrosis-associated HCC models, opposed to controls, Trem-2-/- animals exhibited attenuated fibrosis associated with augmented tumourigenesis. Although this might seem counterintuitive, as fibrosis is a strong risk factor for HCC, importantly these data are consistent with seminal recent single-cell RNA sequencing work demonstrating a pro-fibrogenic role for TREM-2+CD9+ expressing monocyte derived SAMacs in both human and murine CCl4-induced liver cirrhosis.28 Conditioned media from primary human TREM-2 expressing SAMacs, which interestingly exhibits high baseline IL-1β and IL-8 production, promotes collagen expression in primary human HSCs.28 In agreement with this, we observed high TREM-2 expression in cells both infiltrating tumours and inflammatory periportal areas in the surrounding cirrhotic tissue. Furthermore, TREM-2 expression positively correlated with COL1A1, IL1B and IL8 levels. Importantly, our single-cell RNA sequencing analysis was able to expand on these recent findings by demonstrating the presence of infiltrated TREM-2 expressing monocyte-derived macrophages in human HCC tumours that were also CD9+ and CD68+, suggesting they resemble SAMacs. Although, we did not examine TREM-2+CD9+ monocyte-derived macrophage presence in murine HCC tumours, given their recently published presence and profibrogenic role in murine CCl4 fibrosis,28 the absence of fibrosis in Trem-2 -/- versus control animals in the fibrosis-associated hepatocarcinogenesis models makes sense. These findings also support the concept of an uncoupling between the molecular players in fibrosis and HCC.39 40
While the ontogeny of human hepatic macrophages is unknown, in mice, embryonic self-renewing tissue-resident KCs predominate in homeostasis but post-injury, hepatic macrophages derived from circulating monocytes accumulate.64 65 Interestingly, in the naïve state, two murine KC populations have recently been reported, Trem-2 lo and Trem-2 hi, with the Trem-2 hi population predominating in nonalcoholic steatohepatitis models where it is characterised by acquisition of CD9.29 Furthermore, we previously demonstrated that TREM-2 dampened murine CCl4-associated liver injury partly through ROS production within injury-associated inflammatory monocyte-derived macrophages, the recruitment of which depended on TLR4-driven inflammation within HSCs.16 Given that TREM-2 attenuates hepatic damage, inflammation and oxidative stress in the early phases of HCC (figure 3), we hypothesise that HSC or KC expressed TREM-2 serves to dampen infiltration of TREM-2+CD9+ monocyte-derived macrophages in HCC tumours. Although, the relative contribution of these cells to murine and human HCC remains to be determined, here we find that (1) human HCC tumours are rich in TREM-2 expressing monocyte-derived macrophages; (2) Akin to reported effects of TREM-2 expression in KCs, TREM-2 expression in tumour-infiltrated macrophages is associated with TLR signalling and lysosomal pathways16 29; (3) TREM-2 expression in human HCC tumours correlates with inflammation; (4) overexpression of TREM-2 in human HSCs dampens MCP-1 levels and (5) TREM-2 unequivocally plays a protective role in hepatocarcinogenesis.
Interestingly, conditioned media of TREM-2 overexpressing HSCs but not control HSCs inhibited HCC spheroid growth and this was also associated with reduced expression of TNF, MCP1 and canonical Wnt ligands. Blocking Wnt ligand secretion in HSCs abrogated the reduced HCC growth associated with HSC TREM-2 overexpression, adding influences of canonical Wnt signalling to part of TREM’s ‘protective network’ during HCC. These data are consistent with the critical role of β-catenin activation in liver tumourigenesis and its frequent reactivation in HCC51 52 They also underscore the importance of the microenvironment and the tumour promoting effects of HSCs. HSC activation is critical for hepatic tumourigenesis as cotransplantation of only activated HSCs with HCC cells into nude mice promotes tumour growth, an effect partly dependent on HGF.46 66 Here, we demonstrate that in HCC, hepatic Trem-2 levels correlated with HSC activation in the tumour microenvironment and that Hgf is suppressed by TREM-2 during regeneration.
Nonetheless, the protective effects of TREM-2 were apparent at many levels including inflammation, ROS and growth factor production. In this regard, ROS are described to modulate Wnt, growth factor signalling and inflammation.67 68 Administration of antioxidant diets to mice inhibits DEN-mediated hepatocarcinogenesis by reducing ROS and ROS-mediated DNA damage.30 33 Our data demonstrating that the antioxidant BHA is able to almost completely block DEN-induced hepatocarcinogenesis in both genotypes is consistent with these reports, and additionally connects the suppressive effects of TREM-2 on ROS to dampened hepatocyte proliferation and damage. While, admittedly we cannot pinpoint what is the most important contributing effect of TREM-2 to HCC protection, we provide solid evidence that TREM-2 exerts multiple biological effects that likely together contribute to decreased HCC pathogenesis. Our work is also in line with previous observations indicating that the proinflammatory receptor TREM-1, which exerts opposing functions to TREM-2,5 is detrimental in HCC.31 Despite this, we are hesitant to conceptually label TREM-2 as a ‘tumour suppressor’ in HCC.56 In this regard, we and others have shown that TREM-2 is not expressed in mouse hepatocytes and here we observe no TREM-2 expression on transformed human hepatocytes, suggesting insignificant effects of hepatocyte TREM-2 deficiency to the murine DEN model.16 69 Furthermore, to our knowledge, unlike classic tumour suppressor genes such as p53,70 there are no published genome wide association studies supporting that rare TREM-2 variants are associated with HCC risk. Rather, such studies have conclusively demonstrated links with Alzheimer’s disease.10
In summary, all these data indicate that TREM-2 plays a critical role during hepatocarcinogenesis, negatively regulating liver inflammation, oxidative stress and Wnt ligand secretion (figure 9). In this context, TREM-2 prevents hepatocyte proliferation and damage, and consequently HCC development and growth. Thus, by exerting suppressive effects on diverse HCC promoting processes, non-parenchymal TREM-2 represents a central hub that is relevant and critical for HCC pathogenesis. In this regard, the future determination of the TREM-2 ligands will open new avenues for therapeutic interventions. Moreover, our results suggest an importance for investigating TREM-2 agonists. Although cell-type specific TREM-2 agonism is likely challenging, hepatic TREM-2 agonism would presumably attenuate inflammation and oxidative stress in both non-parenchymal hepatic stromal cells and tumour infiltrating monocyte-derived macrophages. Thereby, although, it may prevent hepatocyte damage, proliferation and impact HCC tumour burden in a multifactorial manner, it might be associated with unwarranted effects on fibrosis.
Data availability statement
Data are available upon reasonable request. Email address: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Samples and clinicopathological information were obtained from the Basque Biobank. Samples were processed following standard operation procedures with appropriate approval of the Clinical Research Ethics Committees of the Basque Country and Donostia University Hospital. An informed consent was obtained from all subjects. Clinical Research Ethics Committees of the Basque Country CEIC-E and Donostia University Hospital. ID: PI+CES-BIOEF 2015-01 14-81.
The authors thank the staff of the animal facility, the histology platform at the Biodonostia Health Research Institute and Maialen Arruti Martin from the Molecular Pathology Department of Donostia University Hospital for technical assistance. CIC bioGUNE is recipient of Severo Ochoa Excellence Accreditation by MINECO (SEV-2016-0644). The results published here are in part based upon data generated by the TCGA Research Network: https://www.cancer.gov/tcga. Furthermore, single-cell RNA sequencing analysis was performed on Gene Expression Ominbus data set GSE125449.
AE-B and IL are joint first authors.
JMB and MJP are joint senior authors.
Twitter @andvoge, @jaboeje
Contributors MJP and JMB conceived, designed and coordinated the experiments. AE-B, IL, OS, AA-L, FO, PMR, EH, RJ-A, IR, AL, ALC, MYWZ, PM-G, MA, FE and MJP performed the experiments and obtained the data. AE-B, IL, OS, AA-L, FO, PMR, CJO'R, PM-G, AV, GS, PA, JBA, SK, DAM, LB, JMB and MJP analysed and interpreted the data. EZ, CJO'R and JBA analysed single-cell RNA sequencing data and performed cellular deconvolution and correlation analysis. AE-B, IL, OS, JMB and MJP wrote the manuscript. OS, SK, DAM, LB, JMB and MJP obtained funding. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Funding Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness and 'Instituto de Salud Carlos III' grants (MJP (PI14/00399, PI17/00022 and Ramon y Cajal Programme RYC-2015–17755); JMB (PI12/00380, PI15/01132, PI18/01075, Miguel Servet Programme CON14/00129 and CPII19/00008) cofinanced by 'Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional' (FEDER); CIBERehd: MJP, JMB and LB), Spain; IKERBASQUE, Basque foundation for Science (MJP and JMB), Spain; 'Diputación Foral de Gipuzkoa' (MJP: DFG18/114, DFG19/081; JMB: DFG15/010, DFG16/004); BIOEF (Basque Foundation for Innovation and Health Research: EiTB Maratoia BIO15/CA/016/BD to JMB); Department of Health of the Basque Country (MJP: 2015111100 and 2019111024; JMB: 2017111010), Euskadi RIS3 (JMB: 2016222001, 2017222014, 2018222029, 2019222054, 2020333010) Department of Industry of the Basque Country (JMB: Elkartek: KK-2020/00008) and AECC Scientific Foundation (JMB). AE-B was funded by the University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU) (PIF2014/11) and by the short-term training fellowship Andrew K Burroughs (European Association for the Study of the Liver, EASL). IL and AA-L were funded by the Department of Education, Language Policy and Culture of the Basque Government (PRE_2016_1_0152 and PRE_2018_1_0184). OS and SK were funded by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF25801-B22, FWF-P35168 to OS and L-Mac: F 6104-B21 to SK). FO and DAM were funded by a UK Medical Research Council programme Grant MR/R023026/1. DAM was also funded by the CRUK programme grant C18342/A23390, CRUK/AECC/AIRC Accelerator Award A26813 and the MRC MICA programme grant MR/R023026/1. JBA is supported by the Danish Medical Research Council, Danish Cancer Society, Nordisk Foundation, and APM Foundation. CJO’R and PM-G are supported by Marie Sklodowska-Curie Programme and EASL Sheila Sherlock postdoctoral fellowships.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient and public involvement Patients and/or the public were not involved in the design, or conduct, or reporting or dissemination plans of this research.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.