Table 1

Comparisons of basic experimental immunology and immunology-molecular pathological epidemiology (MPE)

Basic experimental immunologyImmunology-MPE
Research subjectsImmune system in in vivo or in vitro modelsHuman populations
Exposure data (diet, lifestyle, medications, etc.)Easily control and record exposure dataPossible to collect exposure data
Control of environmental or other conditionsYesDifficult; a targeted control can be done by randomised trials
Evaluation of the human immune systemCan be done using human immune cells. It is still a challenge to recapitulate the human immune system in experimental models. Encompassing the complexity of systemic and local tumour-related immunity is difficult.Can be done. It is still a challenge to evaluate immunity status in the local microenvironment if access to tissue is difficult. Encompassing the complexity of systemic and local tumour-related immunity may be possible.
In vivo evaluationPossibleDifficult; can be done by in vivo pathology or molecular imaging
Large sample sizeDifficultPossible
Insight into mechanismsPossibleImmunology-MPE can provide mechanistic insights, which need to be verified by basic experimental research
Generalisability and validity in humansGeneralisability and validity of findings from model systems need to be examined in human populationsAs research on human populations, immunology-MPE can be a validation method for findings from experimental research